Did State Medical Board of Ohio fail its duty in Dr. Raymond Noschang case?

Widow blames Noschang for husband's death
Posted at 7:27 PM, Apr 18, 2019
and last updated 2019-04-18 19:27:21-04

Did the State of Ohio Medical Board fail in its duty to protect patients from Dr. Raymond Noschang?

The attorney for Jan Tyner’s widow says yes.

“People knew what the problem was and they knew how to stop it and they didn't,” attorney Bill Knapp told the 9 On Your Side I-Team.

Noschang, who treated Tyner at the time he died in 2011, is one of 31 medical doctors charged in a federal investigation related to the over-prescribing of opioids.

Tyner’s widow also told the I-Team that state medical regulators should have dealt with Noschang years ago.

“I hold Dr. Noschang fully accountable for my husband's death,” Cheryl Tyner said.

After Jan Tyner died of a drug overdose, the Hamilton County Coroner's Office determined his cause of death was acute oxycodone, fentanyl and alprazolam intoxication - the same drugs he had been prescribed by Noschang.

Cheryl Tyner sued Noschang twice. A wrongful death suit filed in 2012 ended in a mistrial. The second lawsuit ended last year when a jury found Noschang wasn't responsible for Tyner's deadly overdose.

Attorney Knapp said he told the State Medical Board of Ohio in 2012 and 2015 that it needed to investigate Noschang. Knapp said he provided details and a video recording of Noschang's deposition.

Cheryl Tyner said her daughter also wrote a letter to the medical board.

“They just said they were looking into things is what they told us. Never heard from them again,” Cheryl Tyner said.

Last week, a federal grand jury indicted Noschang on eight counts of Unlawful Distribution and Dispensing of Controlled Substances. On the same day - April 10 - the State Medical Board of Ohio notified Noschang he was at risk of losing his medical license for his treatment of a dozen patients since 2010.

The I-Team found other cases suggesting delays to act by the Ohio medical board, including Dr. Saad Sakkal, who was indicted in June 2018 for allegedly running a pill mill.

Seven weeks later, Kentucky issued an emergency order preventing Sakkal from prescribing or dispensing controlled substances. Ohio waited an additional two months to take action.

A jury convicted Sakkal last week of distributing drugs that led to one death.

He has an inactive medical license in Kentucky. In Ohio it's listed as active.

“It's disgusting. It's heartbreaking. It's frustrating,” said Knapp.

A spokeswoman for the State of Ohio Medical Board told the I-Team that Ohio law requires all complaints and investigations to be kept confidential, and that even though there may not be a public record of board action, the information is often shared with law enforcement or other government regulators.

SEE WCPO's continuing coverage, "Conquering Addiction."