Car crashes into apartment: Mother and 3 children 'homeless'

COVID-19 makes search for new home 'really hard'
On March 8 a car crashed into Jermaica McNear's apartment.png
Posted at 4:20 PM, Apr 14, 2020
and last updated 2020-04-15 19:35:41-04

SPRINGDALE, Ohio — A car crashed into Jermaica McNear's Springdale apartment on March 8, forcing her and her three children to live with family and friends. To top that off, an inspector determined it was uninhabitable.

"It's like I have to start all over again," McNear, 27, said. "I really don't know what to do."

Fears about COVID-19 are making her desperate search for a new home seem impossible.

Jermaica McNear
Jermaica McNear

"Some landlords aren't even showing apartments in an effort to keep social distance," said Nick DiNardo, the managing attorney for the nonprofit Legal Aid Society of Southwest Ohio. "It's really hard for a tenant to find a new place at this point."

McNear had lived in a three-bedroom apartment at the Willows of Springdale apartment complex with her 11-year-old, 4-year-old and 1-year-old. She received government housing choice vouchers, formerly known as Section 8, to cover the $1,000 monthly rent.

On March 16, eight days after the car made her home uninhabitable, a woman who identified herself as Natasha Adams, an employee in the property management office, left a voicemail message for McNear.

McNear played the recorded message for the I-Team.

"We actually found an apartment that we can transition you into," Adams said in the voicemail. "It's right across the street from you. It's vacant and ready. You can have that one. ... Corporate office says they'll let you move in before we get the paperwork or anything."

Adams left a second voice mail message for McNear on March 20 confirming the offer to rent her a new apartment.

McNear's cell phone shows on March 31 Adams left a third voice mail message for her in which she said "because of the coronavirus," workers would not do the repairs needed on the unit promised to McNear.

"I can't paint. I can't carpet. I can't clean. I can't do anything," Adams said.

In the March 31 message, Adams said the corporate office was going to release McNear from her lease.

The Willows of Springdale
The Willows of Springdale

On Tuesday, April 14, the day the I-Team interviewed McNear, she returned to her old apartment to begin removing some of her belongings.

McNear said workers were there repairing the damaged apartment so it could be rented.

The website for the apartment complex shows six 3-bedroom apartments are available 'NOW.'

The monthly rent for those apartments is $1,214, about $200 more per month than the housing vouchers that paid for McNear's rent.

The I-Team spoke briefly with two employees in the property management office who declined to identify themselves.

They referred WCPO 9 to TWG, the new corporate owner in Indianapolis.

The new owner

TWG bought the Willows of Springdale apartment complex for $21 million on March 10 -- two days after the crash into McNear's apartment, according to records posted on the website of the Hamilton County Auditor.

The new owner has renamed the property The Park at Springdale.

Ken Bretz, TWG's chief experience officer, told the I-Team that "most of the vacant units were not in a condition that anyone could live in them."

Rehab on vacant units couldn't be classified as "essential" during a pandemic, Bretz said. He added that "we were having a hard time getting vendors out for that type (rehab) of work."

Bretz said the emergency repairs to McNear's old apartment were different than getting a vacant apartment ready for a family of four.

McNear's lease, like all of TWG's leases, does not require the company to provide McNear's family with another apartment, Bretz said.

"We released her from any obligations for the unit," Bretz said.

McNear said she hasn't received her $500 security deposit because she has not collected her belongings from the apartment.

Bretz didn't comment on McNear's security deposit.

McNear told the I-Team she didn't have renter's insurance.

"All of my son's clothes are a total loss," McNear said. "Everything in his room is a total loss. I don't have a home. I want to go home. I want to be in my home. But I can't, and it's hard."

Find WCPO 9 everywhere you stream.

Let the I-Team investigate
Send us your story tips today to
Or call 513-852-4999