Keenan asks fans, "why are you still watching the Reds?"
Also, the crew talks about benching Brandon Phillips, sending J.J Hoover away, decrypting Joey Votto. Plus, discussions on Billy Hamilton's recklessness, Amir Garrett and the future, and Barry Larkin's response about managing the Reds.
The Fifth Mascot is a series featuring Cincinnati Reds beat reporter John Fay.
Each week, John discusses the mighty Redlegs with fans and other journalists.
Listen to full episodes or watch video clips at wcpo.com/fifthmascot.