Gruesome details in Boone County dismemberment case emerge; premeditation to murder admitted
Tom McKee, firstname.lastname@example.org , Brian Mains, WCPO Digital
12:31 PM, Jan 17, 2013
12:43 AM, Jan 19, 2013
BURLINGTON, Ky. - Tears filled Debbie Sterling's eyes Thursday as she sat in a Boone County courtroom and listened to gruesome and graphic details about the murder and dismemberment of Daniel Delfin, 19, of Walton.
The testimony came from Boone County Sheriff's Department Detective Jeremy Rosing, who said the killing was pre-planned by three Northern Kentucky men who were upset Delfin was selling heroin in Walton and Verona.
Det. Rosing said Delfin was beaten, choked, stabbed and once he was dead was dismembered off Messmer Lane in Verona with a machete and saws.
Sterling's interest in the case was purely personal. Her son, Anthony Baumgartner, is one of three men who might face the death penalty at trial.
Jefferey Allen and Stephen Harkness of Verona and Baumgartner, who lives in Florence, are being held without bail at the Boone County Jail on charges of kidnapping, murder, abuse of a corpse and tampering with physical evidence.
Boone District Judge Charles Moore ruled that there was enough evidence in the case to have it presented to a grand jury for consideration.
"He's a good kid," said Sterling said of her son. "I love him."
The current Mississippi resident said she is having a tough time coping with the situation.
"Take the worst thing you can think your child can be accused of doing and multiply it by infinity and beyond," Sterling said.
The police case began on Jan. 14 when Det. Rosing began a missing persons investigation. Delfin's sister reported him missing the day before.
Unknown to everyone but Allen, Baumgartner and Harkness, Delfin was already dead. He'd been killed on Jan. 9 and his body cut up over the next several days.
Records from Delfin's cellphone showed it active until about 6:30 p.m. on Jan. 13. It's last text or call was recorded on a tower in Crittenden. However, that didn't provide enough information to find him.
The break in the case came a short time later when a woman called the Boone County Sheriff's Department to say she'd overheard three men at Baumgartner's Florence apartment talking about kidnapping and assaulting Delfin.
Detectives interviewed the witness in Highland Heights and the information she provided was enough to convince the Boone County Commonwealth Attorney to authorize search warrants for residences in Florence and Verona along with one vehicle.
When police spotted a gray Hyundai the woman said was used in the crime, police stopped it. That was the first time they came into contact with the three men, who agreed to be interviewed.
"In those interviews all three defendants willingly gave information as to the kidnapping, murder, torturing, abuse and tampering with physical evidence," Det. Rosing told the court. "After those interviews with information obtained I placed all three of them under arrest and they were charged with murder, kidnapping, abuse and tampering."
It was during Allen's interview with detectives that police got the first inkling of a motive in the case.
"He did not like the fact that Daniel Delfin was selling drugs in the Walton-Verona area and that he had planned, one week prior to this, he had planned out that he was going to kill Daniel Delfin," Det. Rosing testified.
The three suspects picked up Delfin on High Street in Walton using the ruse that they wanted to buy heroin from him, but needed to go get more money.
Det. Rosing said Harkness drove with Baumgartner next to him in the passenger seat. Allen was in the back next to Delfin. It didn't take long for things to spiral out of control and Det. Rosing testified Allen was identified as the ringleader.
"He proceeded to physically assault Daniel Delfin with his fist, choking and with a metal bar," the detective said. "He continued to assault Daniel through the drive as Daniel was fighting to get away, asking him who he was, why this was happening, kicking the windows and kicking the doors open at which time they kept him inside the car."
At that point, Allen told police that Delfin was unresponsive and that he was snoring as thought he had a concussion or severe trauma to the head.
Once the vehicle reached Messmer Lane, near Allen's House, Delfin was pulled from the back and attacked.
"Mr. Allen slit his throat and stabbed him underneath the rib cage up into the heart and twisted the knife and pulled out," Det. Rosing stated. "They bound Mr. Delfin and then drug him back into the field at which time they rolled the body down the hill, and placed him in a bunch of brush and covered his body and then left."
Testimony indicated that the dismemberment took place over the next several days with Det. Rosing saying Allen again took the lead.
"Using a hatchet and knives, [Allen] began to cut up the body and dismember the body with the head, hands, feet and legs," Det. Rosing said. "He put the body parts into white plastic garbage bags, put them in his mother's SUV vehicle and transported them to a dumpster located at the Super 8 Motel on Dream Street in Florence, Ky."
Contents of that dumpster were trucked to the Rumpke Pendleton County Landfill. Boone County Sheriff's Detectives spent Tuesday coming through thousands of tons of trash looking for evidence there, but came up empty.
The torso and parts of the legs were found at the Verona location. The head, hands, arms and feet remain missing.
When Baumgartner was interviewed, Det. Rosing said he told them he couldn't stand the fact that Delfin was dealing drugs in the area and felt like it was their duty to get rid of him for this.
However, Baumgartner indicated that he didn't believe the initial intent was to murder the 19-year-old.
"He advised that they were supposed to just pick him up on the notion of a drug deal and they were going to assault him and attempt to get information out of him on who he gets his drugs from," Det. Rosing said. "Then, after assaulting Mr. Delfin through a period of time, they would continue to go down the line of finding drug dealers and assaulting them and gathering information out of them and continuing to go up the ladder."
Nonetheless, Det. Rosing said Baumgartner indicated that he assisted with dismembering the body, specifically cutting off the left hand.
"I believe all of them had made admissions that they all partook at some point in the dismemberment of the body," Det. Rosing said. "Exactly what, at this point, I cannot say. I know that Mr. Allen, I believe, did probably the majority of it."
Evidence recovered included a machete, knives, saws and saw blades.
Delfin was preliminarily identified as the victim because of the clothes he was wearing, tatoos on his body and the fact that the trio named him as the victim. DNA will be used to make the final identification.
Detectives took swabs from each of the men Thursday afternoon to use as possible DNA evidence in the case. And they learned that one or some combination of the trio has allegiances to white supremacy groups.
Allen is being represented by public defender Joanne Lynch from LaGrange. She said she was not surprised at the information presented in court, but is skeptical that the whole story has come out.
"We're going to do everything that we can do to really find out what happened in this situation," she said. "I believe there's probably a lot of facts that we didn't hear today that will come out in the process and we're looking forward to getting more information and continuing to represent Jeff."
Baumgartner's attorney is John Delaney from the Kenton County Public Defender's Office. Keith Morgan and Brian Newman from the Boone County Public Defender's Office are representing Harkness.
9 On Your Side reporter Kendall Herold contributed to this report. Follow Kendall on Twitter at @KendallHerold.