COLUMN: Disruptive officiating crew played a role in Xavier loss to NC State

Not a scapegoat, but a factor

DAYTON, Ohio -- It's petty to argue that a game can be decided by referees alone; that certainly wasn't the case Tuesday night when the Xavier Musketeers lost handily to the North Carolina State Wolfpack in the 12th-seed play-in game of the NCAA Tournament , as a lack of offense that involved all five players, sloppy turnovers, poor and uncharacteristic defensive positioning as a team, terrible hedging of screens and a lack of outside presence ultimately doomed Xavier.

But the inconsistency among the three officiants on the floor set a tone that added another adversity for an already struggling squad to overcome.

Xavier did the little things right early: They got the ball to the post where Matt Stainbrook was having his way with whichever NC State forward tried to guard him. They were patient with their shots. They got T.J. Warren, ACC Player of the Year, in foul trouble. Their defense was hands-in-the-face, just-good-enough to keep it close and force shots from beyond 10 feet. They kept steady when Warren caught fire to lead the Wolfpack on a 10-0 scoring run.

Then, as the game sauntered on, the zebras stepped in. Again. And again. And again.

It was a physical game, on and off the ball, but the level of physicality allowed was all over the charts.

It started early on, but began to rear its ugly head and affect XU when Semaj Christon was called for a charging foul with about 8:30 left in the first half on what would have been Warren's third foul, and undoubtedly an exit from the game for the remainder of the half. 

A blocking foul was called five minutes earlier on Justin Martin that was set up much in the same fashion that Christon went to the basket on Warren. 

Again, with just 2.7 seconds remaining in the half, Christon drove to the basket, mostly laterally to the hoop, and was called for a charge. Look at this picture  and examine the position of the left foot of NC State defender Lennard Freeman: It is off the ground. This does not qualify as a charge, per the rules of college basketball, not to mention the double team of body contact initiated by NC State's defense that caused Christon to move on his axis while in the air. 

The trend continued throughout the game on both sides of the ball. Christon drove the lane several other times and went up through blatant contact, but only got the call to go his way once all game. Justin Martin had a handful of shots at the hoop also through arm contact at a 45 degree angle that didn't get a whistle. Dee Davis was all but smothered over the top on almost all of his runs in the key, not to mention the body bumps in the lane. Wolfpack forward BeeJay Anya slapped over the shoulder of a posted up Matt Stainbrook on multiple occasions, and despite picking up four fouls for the game, was frequently given leeway on the contact. NC State hands were all over the center of gravity of anyone who was dribbling across the court at pace.

When the script was flipped, the lightest of body contact was whistled on the other end. There were several instances when Warren drove toward the basket from the perimeter, and when help defense brushed his thigh, the whistle blew. Petty hand-check, reach-in calls were issued that had no affect on offensive direction. Were they actually fouls per league rules? On that end of the court, yes. Not the case at the other basket.

The refs aren't a scapegoat for the terrible team play on offense (.5 assist to turnover ratio), the awful shooting (2-14 from 3-point range, with one of the 3s coming in the closing minutes) and Martin had no business guarding Warren on his own (he made him pay with 25 points), but rarely is there such a direct impact on a team's mental state contributing to the outcome.

RELATED: Xavier coach: We picked the wrong night to play bad

You could see it bubbling after Christon's first foul. He pounded the ball in frustration, and was given a "talking to" by one of the officials. Numerous other times Xavier players threw their recently struck limbs up in the air in frustration after what they conceived to be a foul, but were not agreed with, and as a result of the distraction were slow to get back on defense, leading to an explosive transitional offense for NC State. 

Xavier fought back despite the 6th man on the court for the Wolfpack, coming from 10 points down to within 1 (with 2 minutes left in the first half), from 7 down to within 2 (with 15 minutes left, as close as they would get), even drawing to within 6 points with 9 minutes to go, but overcoming the constant calls that weren't going their way proved to be too much. The expression on the faces of the likes of Dee Davis, Martin and Isaiah Philmore were disheartening. They were beat 8 minutes before this game ended, by both NC State and the referees.

Musketeer faithful will be painfully reminded of 2007's tournament loss to Ohio State, when some similar questionable officiating led to a late Buckeye victory, a game which Xavier mostly controlled. 

The buck stops with Xavier head coach

DAYTON, Ohio -- It's petty to argue that a game can be decided by referees alone; that certainly wasn't the case Tuesday night when the Xavier Musketeers lost handily to the North Carolina State Wolfpack in the 12th-seed play-in game of the NCAA Tournament , as a lack of offense that involved all five players, sloppy turnovers, poor and uncharacteristic defensive positioning as a team, terrible hedging of screens and a lack of outside presence ultimately doomed Xavier.

But the inconsistency among the three officiants on the floor set a tone that added another adversity for an already struggling squad to overcome.

Xavier did the little things right early: They got the ball to the post where Matt Stainbrook was having his way with whichever NC State forward tried to guard him. They were patient with their shots. They got T.J. Warren, ACC Player of the Year, in foul trouble. Their defense was hands-in-the-face, just-good-enough to keep it close and force shots from beyond 10 feet. They kept steady when Warren caught fire to lead the Wolfpack on a 10-0 scoring run.

Then, as the game sauntered on, the zebras stepped in. Again. And again. And again.

It was a physical game, on and off the ball, but the level of physicality allowed was all over the charts.

It started early on, but began to rear its ugly head and affect XU when Semaj Christon was called for a charging foul with about 8:30 left in the first half on what would have been Warren's third foul, and undoubtedly an exit from the game for the remainder of the half. 

A blocking foul was called five minutes earlier on Justin Martin that was set up much in the same fashion that Christon went to the basket on Warren. 

Again, with just 2.7 seconds remaining in the half, Christon drove to the basket, mostly laterally to the hoop, and was called for a charge. Look at this picture  and examine the position of the left foot of NC State defender Lennard Freeman: It is off the ground. This does not qualify as a charge, per the rules of college basketball, not to mention the double team of body contact initiated by NC State's defense that caused Christon to move on his axis while in the air. 

The trend continued throughout the game on both sides of the ball. Christon drove the lane several other times and went up through blatant contact, but only got the call to go his way once all game. Justin Martin had a handful of shots at the hoop also through arm contact at a 45 degree angle that didn't get a whistle. Dee Davis was all but smothered over the top on almost all of his runs in the key, not to mention the body bumps in the lane. Wolfpack forward BeeJay Anya slapped over the shoulder of a posted up Matt Stainbrook on multiple occasions, and despite picking up four fouls for the game, was frequently given leeway on the contact. NC State hands were all over the center of gravity of anyone who was dribbling across the court at pace.

When the script was flipped, the lightest of body contact was whistled on the other end. There were several instances when Warren drove toward the basket from the perimeter, and when help defense brushed his thigh, the whistle blew. Petty hand-check, reach-in calls were issued that had no affect on offensive direction. Were they actually fouls per league rules? On that end of the court, yes. Not the case at the other basket.

The refs aren't a scapegoat for the terrible team play on offense (.5 assist to turnover ratio), the awful shooting (2-14 from 3-point range, with one of the 3s coming in the closing minutes) and Martin had no business guarding Warren on his own (he made him pay with 25 points), but rarely is there such a direct impact on a team's mental state contributing to the outcome.

RELATED: Xavier coach: We picked the wrong night to play bad

You could see it bubbling after Christon's first foul. He pounded the ball in frustration, and was given a "talking to" by one of the officials. Numerous other times Xavier players threw their recently struck limbs up in the air in frustration after what they conceived to be a foul, but were not agreed with, and as a result of the distraction were slow to get back on defense, leading to an explosive transitional offense for NC State. 

Xavier fought back despite the 6th man on the court for the Wolfpack, coming from 10 points down to within 1 (with 2 minutes left in the first half), from 7 down to within 2 (with 15 minutes left, as close as they would get), even drawing to within 6 points with 9 minutes to go, but overcoming the constant calls that weren't going their way proved to be too much. The expression on the faces of the likes of Dee Davis, Martin and Isaiah Philmore were disheartening. They were beat 8 minutes before this game ended, by both NC State and the referees.

Musketeer faithful will be painfully reminded of 2007's tournament loss to Ohio State, when some similar questionable officiating led to a late Buckeye victory, a game which Xavier mostly controlled. 

The buck stops with Xavier head coach

Print this article Back to Top

Comments

or Subscribe now so you can share your opinion! It’s only a penny for a month trial.

Latest Forecast
More XU Sports
Former XU guard Semaj Christon drafted by Heat
Former XU guard Semaj Christon drafted by Heat

Former Xavier University guard Semaj Christon was selected by the Miami Heat with the 25th pick in the second round…

Xavier pitcher selected by Mariners in MLB Draft
Xavier pitcher selected by Mariners in MLB Draft

Xavier baseball player Vinny Nittoli was selected by the Seattle Mariners in the 25th round of the 2014 Major League…

Martin picks SMU; XU's loss becomes UC's, too
Martin picks SMU; XU's loss becomes UC's, too

Former Xavier forward Justin Martin is transferring to Southern Methodist, which means XU's loss becomes UC's loss, too.

XU blows lead, falls in 10 in elimination game
XU blows lead, falls in 10 in elimination game

Aaron Payne led off the 10th inning with a walk, stole second and scored the tiebreaking run on Xavier's fifth error in Oregon's 11-8…

Xavier tops Clemson, stays alive in NCAA tourney
Xavier tops Clemson, stays alive in NCAA tourney

Daniel Rizzie doubled and drove in a pair of runs to lead Xavier to their second ever NCAA baseball tournament victory, 6-4 over Clemson on…

Xavier no match for Vandy in NCAA tourney rout
Xavier no match for Vandy in NCAA tourney rout

The Xavier Musketeers must have wondered what hit them in their NCAA baseball tournament opener Friday night.

DJ: Grateful for the life of Tom Siemers
DJ: Grateful for the life of Tom Siemers

Always grateful for his faith, his family, his country, his school, his career and his friends, Tom Siemers lived a life that touched others.

XU baseball, coach try to make NCAA statement
XU baseball, coach try to make NCAA statement

Not many people are giving Xavier a chance in Friday night's regional opener against Vanderbilt. And their manager wouldn't have it…

Xavier plays host Vanderbilt in NCAA baseball
Xavier plays host Vanderbilt in NCAA baseball

The Musketeers continue their surprising postseason in Nashville, Tenn., on Friday.

XU headed to NCAAs after 5-0 Big East final win
XU headed to NCAAs after 5-0 Big East final win

The Xavier baseball team secured its second-ever berth in the NCAA tournament with a 5-0 win over Creighton on Sunday in the Big East…