NEW YORK, SEPT. 8, 2011 - A man plays piano at the top of one of the World Trade Center buildings with a view of New York City in the background. Brendan Keefe
Hide Caption
NEW YORK, NY - SEPTEMBER 11: Family members who lost loved ones bring flowers to the memorial during tenth anniversary ceremonies of the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks at the World Trade Center site September 11, 2011 in New York City. The nation is commemorating the tenth anniversary of the terrorist attacks which resulted in the deaths of nearly 3,000 people after two hijacked planes crashed into the World Trade Center, one into the Pentagon in Arlington, Virginia and one crash landed in Shanksville, Pennsylvania. (Photo by David Handschuh-Pool/Getty Images)
Hide Caption

Sifting of Sept. 11 debris for remains begins anew

a a a a
Share this story

NEW YORK (AP) - Jim Riches pulled his son's mangled body out of the rubble at the World Trade Center, but the phone calls still filtered in years afterward. The city kept finding more pieces of his son.

"They'll call you and they'll tell you, `We found a shin bone,'" Riches said. "Or: `We found an arm bone.' We held them all together and then we put them in the cemetery."

Those are the phone calls both dreaded and hoped for among the families of Sept. 11 victims. And as investigators began sifting through newly uncovered debris from the World Trade Center on Monday for the first time in three years, those anxieties were renewed more than a decade after the attacks. But there was also hope that more victims might yet be identified after tens of millions have been spent on the painstaking identification process.

"We would like to see the other 40 percent of the families who have never recovered anything to at least someday have a piece of their loved one," Riches said. "That they can go to a cemetery and pray."

About 60 truckloads of debris that could contain tiny fragments of bone or tissue were unearthed by construction crews that have been working on the new World Trade Center in recent years. That material is now being transported to a park built on top of the former Fresh Kills landfill on Staten Island, where investigators will attempt to identify any possible remains during the next 10 weeks, the city said.

The city's last sifting effort ended in 2010. This time, crews were able to dig up parts of the trade center site that were previously inaccessible to workers, the city said.

Some 2,750 people died at the World Trade Center in the 2001 terrorist attacks, but only 1,634 people have been identified.

"We have been monitoring the World Trade Center site over time and monitoring the construction," said Ellen Borakove, a spokeswoman for the medical examiner's office. "And if they see any material that could possibly contain human remains, we collect that material."

About 9,000 human remains recovered from the ruins of the World Trade Center remain unidentified because they are too degraded to match victims by DNA identification. The remains are stored at an undisclosed location monitored by the medical examiner's office and will eventually be transferred to a subterranean chamber at the National September 11 Memorial & Museum.

Some victims' families expressed impatience that the city has only just uncovered more debris.

"Quite frankly, they should've excavated this and searched it 12 years ago," said Diane Horning, whose son, Matthew, died in the attacks. "Instead, they built service roads and construction roads and were more worried about the building and the tourism than they were about the human remains."

The city's efforts to identify Sept. 11 victims have long been fraught with controversy.

In April 2005, the city's chief medical examiner, Charles Hirsch, told families his office would be suspending identification efforts because it had exhausted the limits of DNA technology.

But just a year later, the discovery of human remains on a bank tower roof and then in a manhole near ground zero outraged families who said the search for their loved ones had been rushed initially. The findings prompted a renewed search that cost the city tens of millions of dollars and uncovered 1,500 pieces of remains.

Meanwhile, some victims' relatives sued the city over its decision to move 1.6 million tons of materials from the trade center site to the Fresh Kills landfill, saying the material might contain victims' ashes and should have been given a proper burial.

The lawsuit was dismissed, and unsuccessfully appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court.

As it embarks on combing through debris yet again, the medical examiner's office says it will keep monitoring the site as long as new areas are being dug or exposed.

Charles G. Wolf was pleased to hear about the renewed search, though he believes that his wife, Katherine, was vaporized during the attack. Investigators have never found her remains.

Years ago, it bothered him that he had no grave to visit. Wolf said the opening of the Sept. 11 memorial has filled a hole in his heart, but he'll never have closure.

"You heal. You carry on," he said. "It's not closure."

---

Associated Press Writer Jennifer Peltz contributed to this report.

Copyright Copyright 2013 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Print this article

Comments

Hmm... It looks like you’re not a WCPO Insider. or Subscribe now to contribute!

More 9/11 Stories
Congress renews foreign surveillance law
Congress renews foreign surveillance law

The Senate gave final approval Friday to a bill renewing the government's authority to monitor overseas phone calls and emails of suspected…

European ct. condemns CIA program
European ct. condemns CIA program

A European court issued a landmark ruling Thursday that condemned the CIA's so-called extraordinary renditions programs and bolstered those…

US: Guantanamo death was suicide
US: Guantanamo death was suicide

An autopsy has found that a Guantanamo Bay prisoner who died in September committed suicide, a U.S. military official said Thursday.

Emails offer details on bin Laden burial
Emails offer details on bin Laden burial

Internal emails among senior U.S. military officers indicate that no sailors watched Osama bin Laden's burial at sea from the USS Carl Vinson…

Court: Alleged torture victims can't sue
Court: Alleged torture victims can't sue

A federal appeals court in Chicago has ruled that two American contractors allegedly tortured by U.S. forces in Iraq can't sue former Defense…

WTC Memorial reopens after storm
WTC Memorial reopens after storm

The National Sept. 11 Memorial & Museum reopened Tuesday in Lower Manhattan, leaving just a few major New York City landmarks — including…

Is it time for a different kind of 9/11?
Is it time for a different kind of 9/11?

Victims' families and others were poised to gather and grieve Tuesday at ground zero, the Pentagon and near Shanksville , Pa., for the…

Tri-State victims of 9/11 remembered
Tri-State victims of 9/11 remembered

We remember and honor those who died in the 9/11 attacks who were from or had connections to the Tri-State.

Both campaigns eschew politics on 9/11
Both campaigns eschew politics on 9/11

It could be the only day before Nov. 6 without explicit partisan rancor.

Tall task to compensate ill 9/11 workers
Tall task to compensate ill 9/11 workers

Sheila Birnbaum is known in legal circles across New York as the "queen of torts" for her prowess in sorting out complicated cases. But she…