Photo Video
Jenell Walton
Hide Caption

Appeals court rejects delay of Cincinnati's parking lease

Case now headed to Ohio Supreme Court

a a a a
Share this story

CINCINNATI - An appellate court ruled Monday morning to deny a request to block Cincinnati officials from implementing a controversial parking lease.

The First District Court of Appeals denied a motion to stay the decision it issued Wednesday in the city's favor.

Parking lease opponents still plan an appeal to the Ohio Supreme Court, their attorney said Monday.

"Before the New York interests issue the bonds (for the parking lease), this could go before the Supreme Court," said attorney Curt Hartman.

"This is not dead," Hartman added. "I would think a New York investment bank would not want to issue the bonds with this uncertainty over the lease still hanging in the air."

In its 2-1 decision June 12, the appellate court ruled the Common Pleas Court acted appropriately when it issued the injunction March 27, but erred when it later ruled the city's charter didn't clearly state that officials could use emergency ordinances.

In his March ruling, Common Pleas Court Judge Robert Winkler had said city council's use of an emergency clause to have the lease take effect immediately does not supersede provisions in the city's charter or Ohio law that ensures the right to referendum for most legislative actions.

In a 5-4 vote in March, city council approved a decades-long lease of city-owned parking meters, lots and garages to the Port Authority using an emergency ordinance. The vote occurred just 15 days after the plan was unveiled publicly and presented to city council.

Councilman Chris Seelbach, who opposed the lease, then provided the sixth vote necessary to enable the city to enact it as an emergency ordinance, which officials thought would make it immune to referendum.

Shortly thereafter, however, the citizens group got an injunction from the Hamilton County Common Pleas Court against the action.

Under the deal, the city's parking meters would be leased to the Port Authority for 30 years, while the city's parking lots and garages would be leased for up to 50 years.

In return, the city would get a $92 million upfront payment, along with annual payments of about $3 million for the remainder of the lease.

City officials planned to use the money to help avoid deficits in the 2014 and 2015 budgets, and to quicken the pace of some citywide development projects. Instead, they used other sources of money to fill gaps in the budget, which was approved in late May.

A New York-based financial consultant hired by the city to analyze the lease said the city would get $197.4 million – or 41 percent of its current market value. The remainder of the lease's value will go to the Port Authority, private contractors and a New York investment bank that will issue debt to support the deal.

Opponents said the lease would cause rate increases and aggressive enforcement might drive away customers from small businesses, while some residents said the city was undervaluing a prime city asset.

Copyright 2013 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Print this article

Comments

Hmm... It looks like you’re not a WCPO Insider. or Subscribe now to contribute!

More Parking Stories
Cranley parking plan: Enforcement hours grow
Cranley parking plan: Enforcement hours grow

Under a proposed deal, the Port Authority would issue bonds to pay for meter upgrades, but City Hall keeps control.

Sen. Sherrod Brown: Raise minimum wage
Sen. Sherrod Brown: Raise minimum wage

This week, Kevin Osborne interviews U.S. Sen Sherrod Brown (D-Ohio).

Critics blast police, fire layoff plan
Critics blast police, fire layoff plan

Some say Mayor Mark Mallory and City Council are ignoring budget cutting options besides police and firefighter layoffs.

City gets lower value in parking deal
City gets lower value in parking deal

New documents released by City Hall reveal Cincinnati may be leasing its parking system for less than half its market value over the next 30…

City manager signs parking lease
City manager signs parking lease

In a 17-word message on Twitter, the city of Cincinnati announced Tuesday afternoon that the city manager has signed a controversial parking lease.

Parking deal goes ahead despite protest
Parking deal goes ahead despite protest

A controversial lease of the city of Cincinnati’s parking system will likely take effect within the next week, despite efforts to repeal it.

Cincinnati mayoral candidates face off
Cincinnati mayoral candidates face off

It wasn’t exactly a debate, but the two major candidates seeking to be Cincinnati’s next mayor shared a stage this morning to…

What does Cincinnati Port Authority do?
What does Cincinnati Port Authority do?

The Port of Greater Cincinnati Development Authority has lots of wheels in motion these days, including a controversial parking lease with…

Port CEO: Sorry for parking email
Port CEO: Sorry for parking email

A 10-word email from the Port Authority's top official is prompting new questions about whether information is being deliberately concealed…

Cincinnati's economic director resigns
Cincinnati's economic director resigns

After a little more than a year on the job, Cincinnati's economic development director is resigning next month.