File photo of a snowstorm
Hide Caption

Do windshield ice melters really work?

Don't Waste Your Money

a a a a
Share this story

The last thing you need when you're trying to get out the door on a cold morning is a windshield that won't defrost, as rain or snow refreezes on your car.

So we tested three de-icer sprays to see if they really work.

We bought de-icers made by Rain-x, Prestone, and Blue Coral.

Ideally, these are for ice, not snow, but we decided to spray them on our news van that had both ice and snow on its windshield.

Blue Coral

I sprayed a third of the windshield with Blue Coral. It sprayed nicely, but the trigger was a bit stiff to use.

Anyone with arthritic fingers might want to choose the second or third option.

Prestone

The Prestone had the easiest to use trigger, taking little effort. Other than that, it went on similarly.

Rain-x

Finally, I sprayed the Rain-x. I then waited 10 minutes.

All of them melted through the snow and ice, to reveal glass.

But after looking closely, the Blue Coral appeared to do a slightly better job, continuing to melt the new snow that continued to fall. The others started to allow new snow to accumulate on the windshield.

But Prestone and Rain-x were almost as effective, and since snow melting is not really what they are designed for, we had to declare a tie in the end.

A cheaper solution?

So the bottom line: All three worked, which means you may want to choose yours based on which one is on sale.

These de icers are not exactly cheap, so frugal living websites suggest you make your own, with a solution of one third vinegar, one third rubbing alcohol, and one third water.

Though it may not be as strong as the professional sprays, that one dollar home solution may be all you need, and you don't waste your money.d

For my report on driveway ice melters, CLICK HERE .

_________________

Don't Waste Your Money is a registered trademark of the EW Scripps Co

"Like" John Matarese on Facebook

Follow John on Twitter (@DWYM)

Copyright 2013 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Print this article

Comments

Hmm... It looks like you’re not a WCPO Insider. or Subscribe now to contribute!

More DWYM
Consumer investigation: Store scanner errors
Consumer investigation: Store scanner errors

John Matarese goes undercover to find store cash registers with the most errors

Cincinnati gas prices jump to 8-month high
Cincinnati gas prices jump to 8-month high

John Matarese looks into the rising price of gasoline

Need MRI or CT scan? How to save hundreds
Need MRI or CT scan? How to save hundreds

John Matarese shows a great alternative to expensive hospital scans

Free Shred Day this Saturday
Free Shred Day this Saturday

John Matarese has details on a  major free shredding event

Apps that can be dangerous for children
Apps that can be dangerous for children

Is it really a friend or is it a predator? Unless you are actively monitoring your child's smartphone and tablet apps, you are not…

Gasoline, beef prices soaring
Gasoline, beef prices soaring

John Matarese looks into higher prices hitting just as spring arrives

'Heartbleed' flaw exposes millions of passwords
'Heartbleed' flaw exposes millions of passwords

An alarming lapse in Internet security has exposed millions of passwords, credit card numbers and other sensitive bits of information to…

How to save BIG on Reds tickets
How to save BIG on Reds tickets

If you couldn't make it to Opening Day, there’s still plenty of time to see the Cincinnati Reds this season – and for cheap.

"One Ring" phone scam getting worse

John Matarese warns about the "One-Ring" scam

Cobalt, Saturn owners anxious for repair
Cobalt, Saturn owners anxious for repair

John Matarese reports on the wait for ignition switch repairs