Photo Video
Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine Dwayne Slavey
Hide Caption

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine formally announces use of facial recognition 2 months after launch

Says his office should have notified public

a a a a
Share this story
Show Related Headlines
Related Articles
Police increase use of cameras

CINCINNATI -- Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine formally announced the use of facial recognition technology Monday, but in hindsight said his office should have notified the public of its existence two months ago.

Since June 6, law enforcement agencies throughout the state completed 2,677 facial recognition searches by tapping into the existing Bureau of Motor Vehicles database.

For example, throughout the course of an investigation, law enforcement officials may obtain an image of a suspect from surveillance video and, for the last two months, have been able to crosscheck a photo using the BMV’s database of driver’s license photos using facial recognition technology, DeWine said at a press conference in Columbus.

The system has been in development for the last three years, DeWine said. Approximately 28 states and the FBI employ some sort of facial recognition technology, DeWine said.

DeWine told reporters he didn't think he needed to notify the public about the program's launch because it's been long discussed during meetings with law enforcement agencies and groups.

Plus, he said, officers have had the ability for decades to access photos and records from the Bureau of Motor Vehicles. "It's a natural extension of what law enforcement has done in the past," he said.

“If I had to do it over again, we would have put out a release the day it went up,” DeWine said.

Law enforcement agencies have always been able to access BMV records through the Ohio Law Enforcement Gateway (OHLEG), but the use of facial recognition technology is an added tool, DeWine said.

The technology works by measuring points on a human face, such as the length of a person’s nose or the shape of a person’s cheekbones and the width between a person’s eyes, DeWine said.

“It is not as exact, certainly, as DNA or as exact as fingerprints,” DeWine said. “Its purpose is to give the investigator a lead that he or she can follow-up on.”

The technology is geared toward harnessing the increasing use of surveillance cameras that are becoming a standard investigative tool, including Cincinnati. There are approximately 130 cameras in the city today and plans call for the installation of more with the use of federal grants funds.

The six officers at the city’s real-time crime center have pulled video from the city’s 130 cameras 74 times through Aug. 1. That’s compared to 93 in all of 2012 and 57 times in 2011, according to Lt. Lisa Thomas, supervisor of CPD’s intelligence unit.

Through a series of Port Security Grant Program grants, a function of the Department of Homeland Security, CPD is able to access and operate some 25 cameras along the Ohio River. There are plans to increase the that number to 30 and to have surveillance stretching west to the Caroll C. Cropper Bridge and east to Combs-Hehl Bridge, said Barry Whitton, a computer systems analyst with CPD’s technology and systems section.

Law enforcement officials follow the same rules used for accessing information through OHLEG, a web-based platform accessing a number of databases, including the computerized criminal history files, the electronic sexual offender registration and notification, department of rehabilitation and correction, BMV, LEADS and the Ohio Law Enforcement Sharing Network, according to the attorney general’s office.

There are no routine audits of law enforcement’s use of facial recognition technology or database, rather, prosecution of any misuse is primarily done through people reporting others’ abuse, DeWine said.

“The best deterrent is jail,” DeWine said.

Misuse is a fifth-degree felony, said Jill Del Greco, spokeswoman for the attorney general’s office.

“I’ve asked our team to go back and try to gather information about how its being used, so we can then turn that over (to an independent group),” DeWine said.

DeWine’s office is assembling an independent group of judges, lawyers and other law enforcement officials to review practices and protocols of the facial recognition technology, but the details and who will sit on the “working group” has not been finalized, Del Greco said. She expected that information to be finalized later this week.

“The time for press conferences and advisory boards was months ago,” said ACLU of Ohio Associate Director Gary Daniels. “This system needs to be shut down until there are meaningful, documented rules in place to keep this information secure, protect the privacy of innocent people, and prevent government abuse of this new tool.”

Previously, law enforcement officials needed a name or address to search the state database of license photos and mug shots. Now, police officers and even civilian employees can use a simple photo to search these databases for names and contact information.

Associated Press writer Ann Sanner contributed to this report.

Copyright 2013 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Print this article

More Ohio News
Ohio state park facilities to be modernized
Ohio state park facilities to be modernized

State officials are preparing to invest $88.5 million to upgrade and modernize trails, campgrounds and recreational facilities in Ohio's…

More than 73K vote early in Ohio primary
More than 73K vote early in Ohio primary

More than 73,000 Ohioans have voted early so far in the state's primary election next month.

Court: Ohio man must pay $489,000 for false call
Court: Ohio man must pay $489,000 for false call

An appeals court says an Ohio man whose false distress call triggered a massive, 21-hour search on Lake Erie must pay $489,000 to the U.S.…

Steubenville coach gets jail in rape case
Steubenville coach gets jail in rape case

A volunteer football coach whose house was the scene of a party that preceded the rape of a girl by two high school football players has…

No contest plea expected in football rape case
No contest plea expected in football rape case

A volunteer football coach whose house was the scene of a party that preceded the rape of a girl by two high school football players is…

Should OH politicians be able to lie in ads?
Should OH politicians be able to lie in ads?

A debate over what is truth and the nature of free speech born out of the 2010 campaign of former U.S. Representative…

Gender gap widens in Ohio statewide offices
Gender gap widens in Ohio statewide offices

The average pay gap between men and women in the offices of four of Ohio’s five elected statewide officials has grown to almost $10 an hour.

Gender gap under OH governor nearly $10 an hour
Gender gap under OH governor nearly $10 an hour

 A newspaper investigation has found the average pay gap between men and women in the offices of four of Ohio's five elected…

Want to name a blimp? Goodyear opens voting
Want to name a blimp? Goodyear opens voting

Ohio-based Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co. has narrowed the list of possible names for the new airship that is the next generation of its…

Ohio woman finds bird leg in Dole spinach bag
Ohio woman finds bird leg in Dole spinach bag

An Ohio woman, who eats a salad nearly every day and makes spinach smoothies, has lost her appetite for her favorite vegetable after making a…