Ohio Supreme Court Chief Justice: Time to change how judges elected

O'Connor talks about possible changes in visit

a a a a
Share this story
Show Related Headlines
Related Articles
Chief justice: No judge age requirement
Tracie Hunter indicted, cannot act as judge
Ohio Supreme Court: Judge Hunter in contempt

UNION TOWNSHIP -- On the same day that a Hamilton County judge was indicted on eight felony charges, the Ohio Supreme Court’s chief justice was in the region trying to garner support for changing how judges are selected.

Chief Justice Maureen O’Connor spoke in Clermont County about the public’s bleak view of the judiciary and voter apathy about electing judges.

Although O’Connor was asked about Friday’s indictment of Hamilton County Juvenile Court Judge Tracie Hunter, she declined comment on the case.

But the chief justice said criminal indictment of any judge emphasizes the need for greater public education and involvement when choosing judges.

“We have about 730 judges (in Ohio),” O’Connor told a crowd at a Union Township luncheon. “Sometimes they err in their judgment and they cross the line, and they’re removed for it."

“I think it’s evidence we need to have better information before the public before they elect members of the judiciary,” she added.

As part of the ongoing process to suggest changes for modernizing and improving Ohio’s constitution, O’Connor has been leading a public discussion about judicial elections.

Ohio’s constitutional modernization process began in 2011 and will last a decade. The commission, consisting of 12 legislators — six Democrats and six Republicans — along with 20 non-legislators, will make recommendations to the General Assembly if they are agreed upon by a two-thirds vote.

Any proposals will only go before voters if they are approved by three-fifths of the members of the Ohio House and Senate.

O’Connor has been speaking about a multi-point plan to overhaul judicial elections. The judge said she doesn’t necessarily agree with every aspect, but thinks they are ideas that should be fully reviewed and debated.

Among the possible changes:

  • Rotating the order of state offices on the ballot, so judges aren’t listed last;
  • Moving state and county judicial elections to odd-numbered years, where they may get more attention away from high-profile races like president, Congress and governor;
  • Eliminating party affiliation in primary elections for judicial candidates, and switch to an open primary system;
  • Centralizing and expanding public education about how the judicial system operates, including creating a database listing the qualifications and experience of all candidates; and
  • Increasing the basic qualifications needed to run for a judgeship. Currently, a person in Ohio only has to have been a practicing attorney for six years.

Public attitudes suggest some change is needed.

A poll by the National Center for State Courts found that 59 percent of Americans believe courts' decisions are influenced by politics. Also, a 2012 poll found that the U.S. Supreme Court's public approval rating was just 44 percent, an all-time low.

“There is an over-arching belief that judges make their decisions based on politics and based on special interest groups,” O’Connor said. “We need to do something to dispel that notion among the citizenry.”

Most judges don’t let their personal beliefs influence their rulings, she added.

“Judges can only make their decisions on the facts presented in court,” O’Connor said.

“There is no such thing as a Republican judge or a Democratic judge,” she said. Admonishing colleagues who may let ideology sway them, O’Connor continued, “if that is the case, I’m sorry but you’re violating your oath of office and you should hang up your robe. I feel very strongly about that.”

A Republican, O’Connor noted she has ruled in cases involving labor unions and healthcare that favored traditionally Democratic viewpoints.

Part of the problem, O’Conner said, is popular TV shows that feature surly retired judges haranguing plaintiffs and defendants for entertainment.

“Those judges are disrespectful, snarky – the antithesis of what a judge is supposed to be,” she said.

Ohio voters have twice rejected measures to have judges appointed based on merit instead of elected, in 1937 and 1987. As such, O’Connor believes elections are here to stay but should be improved.

But many people choose not to vote for judicial candidates while at the polls, either through indifference or ignorance. Typically, between 20 percent and 45 percent of voters don’t make judicial selections, a trend known as “voter fatigue.”

“It’s almost counter-intuitive,” O’Connor said. “They say they want to vote for judges but they don’t do it… we have to bolster the presence of the judiciary in the minds of the electorate.”

O'Connor, 62, is the 10th chief justice in Ohio history, and the first woman to lead the judicial branch.

A former lieutenant governor under Bob Taft, O’Conner was elected to the Ohio Supreme Court in 2002. She was reelected in 2008, and appointed chief justice by then-Gov. Ted Strickland in May 2010.

Copyright 2014 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Print this article


Hmm... It looks like you’re not a WCPO Insider. or Subscribe now to contribute!

More Gov't & Politics
Educators gather to plot Cincy school success
Educators gather to plot Cincy school success

Advocates for Cincinnati Public Schools have been telling all who will listen that their development of Community Learning Centers are an…

RNC team to visit Cincinnati late April
RNC team to visit Cincinnati late April

The two Ohio cities still in contention to host the 2016 Republican National Convention will be visited in late April by party staff or…

Mahogany's makes payment to cure default
Mahogany's makes payment to cure default

Mahogany's on the Banks met its Friday deadline for curing its default with its landlord and avoided eviction.

Boehner buys TV ad time in his Ohio district
Boehner buys TV ad time in his Ohio district

House Speaker John Boehner is spending $125,000 on television ads in his Ohio district to fend off three fellow Republicans in the primary.

RNC picks Cincinnati to move forward with bid
RNC picks Cincinnati to move forward with bid

Cincinnati is one of six cities picked to move forward with its bid to host the 2016 Republican National Convention.

Mahogany's faces eviction unless it pays Apr. 11
Mahogany's faces eviction unless it pays Apr. 11

Mahogany's on the Banks made another required minimum payment Tuesday, but the troubled restaurant has to pay about $25,000 more in 10…

Reading mayor's roots are 3 generations deep
Reading mayor's roots are 3 generations deep

Bo Bemmes is proud of Reading's claim to fame as home of John Boehner--not to mention the world's largest bridal district.

Pause in streetcar construction cost city $1M
Pause in streetcar construction cost city $1M

A nearly three-week pause in streetcar construction in December cost Cincinnati almost $1 million, city officials said Tuesday.

Cranley, Blackwell attending DOJ policing forum
Cranley, Blackwell attending DOJ policing forum

Police Chief Jeffrey Blackwell and Mayor John Cranley will attend a Department of Justice Forum next week, touting the city’s progress…

North Bend mayor leads village with big history
North Bend mayor leads village with big history

Douglas Sammons presides over the historic village named for its location where the Ohio River meanders to the north.