Matt Alder head of Cincinnati Firefighters Union
Hide Caption

Cincinnati mayoral race: Firefighters' union endorses John Cranley for mayor

9 others get council endorsement

a a a a
Share this story

CINCINNATI -- A labor union representing Cincinnati’s firefighters has endorsed John Cranley in the mayoral race.

The International Association of Fire Fighters (IAFF) Local 48 announced the endorsement Friday, capping off a week that saw Cranley take the top spot in Tuesday’s mayoral primary election.

“When Local 48 endorses a candidate for office, we keep the basic principle of ‘support those who support us’ in mind,” said Matt Alter, Local 48 president.

A major factor behind the endorsement is recent city budgets that initially called for firefighter layoffs, although the layoffs were avoided by the time City Council passed the final spending plans.

Firefighter and police layoffs have been proposed every year from 2009 to 2013. City Council ultimately avoided layoffs each time by finding other cuts to avoid looming deficits.

For example, the budget plan released by City Manager Milton Dohoney Jr. in March proposed laying off 189 police officers and 80 firefighters.

City Council made changes to the plan throughout spring. In late May, layoff notices were mailed to 66 police officers and 71 firefighters. But about a week later, a budget was approved that included no layoffs.

Police and firefighters have criticized the tactic, stating the threat of layoffs has been used to achieve political goals like getting public support for the city’s controversial parking lease plan.

“It’s definitely a factor,” Alter said, referring to the role periodic layoff notices played in the endorsement.

An ex-city councilman, Cranley is running against Vice Mayor Roxanne Qualls. Both are Democrats, and both have helped shape city budgets during the past decade.

Qualls has chaired City Council’s budget and finance committee since 2010. Cranley chaired the committee from December 2001 to January 2009.

“When I was head of the finance committee for eight budget cycles, it was unthinkable to threaten layoffs of police and firefighters,” Cranley said. “In fact, we added them.”

Cranley referred to the hiring of 115 police officers in the years shortly after the 2001 riots. The hirings have become an issue in this year’s mayoral campaign because, at the time, then-Police Chief Thomas Streicher Jr. said he hadn’t requested them.

“We went through a recession while I was on council, but we didn’t consider those departments for layoffs because that was at odds with our value system,” Cranley said.

Jens Sutmoller, Qualls’ campaign manager, is puzzled by the union’s support for Cranley. It was Qualls who worked to find alternate cuts to avoid firefighter layoffs this year, he said.

“Roxanne has a track record of results creating clean and safe neighborhoods,” Sutmoller said. “In the latest budget, Roxanne saved firefighters and police officers from layoffs and is proud of her long list of endorsements.”

In recent years, the Cincinnati Fire Department has seen staffing shortages that have caused “brownouts.” A brownout is when one truck in a firehouse is idled.

Cincinnati has experienced between one and five brownouts daily, Alter said. The department’s ranks are stretched too thin, which jeopardizes public safety, he added.

The Cincinnati Fire Department currently has 786 personnel. But the number needed to end brownouts and become fully staffed is 879.

A recruit class will graduate in February that should bring the ranks up to 826 people, Alter said. Still, 35 people likely will retire in 2014, offsetting some of the increase.

“We’re still about 50 short of our goal,” Alter said.

Some of Qualls’ supporters took to the Internet to downplay the endorsement.

“They endorsed Pepper in 2005, Wenstrup in 2009,” tweeted Craig Hochscheid, the blogger known as Cincy Cappel.

Hochscheid referred to mayoral candidates David Pepper and Brad Wenstrup, each of whom lost their respective races.

The IAFF also endorsed a slate of candidates for City Council.

The slate included incumbents Chris Seelbach, Yvette Simpson, P.G. Sittenfeld, Christopher Smitherman, Pam Thomas, Wendell Young and Charlie Winburn; and challengers Kevin Flynn and Greg Landsman.

 Qualls and Laure Quinlivan are the only incumbents who weren’t endorsed.

The Fraternal Order of Police is scheduled to announce its endorsements Sept. 26, said union President Kathy Harrell.

Copyright 2013 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Print this article


Hmm... It looks like you’re not a WCPO Insider. or Subscribe now to contribute!

More Mayoral Race Stories
WATCH: Final Cincinnati mayoral debate
WATCH: Final Cincinnati mayoral debate

In the last major debate before Cincinnati voters cast ballots for the next mayor, Roxanne Qualls emphasized her experience while John…

Qualls and Cranley on the issues
Qualls and Cranley on the issues

A quick guide to where Roxanne Qualls and John Cranley stand on the issues in Cincinnati's mayoral race.

John Cranley has unpaid $75,000 loan
John Cranley has unpaid $75,000 loan

A nonprofit firm made the loan in 2009 to help build a medical office facility in East Price Hill.

Qualls brings Kansas City mayor to town
Qualls brings Kansas City mayor to town

Cincinnati mayoral candidate Roxanne Qualls has Sly James, mayor of Kansas City, Mo., explain the importance of streetcars to revitalizing…

Qualls defends real estate sales near streetcar
Qualls defends real estate sales near streetcar

Roxanne Qualls says criticism of her property sales near the streetcar is unfounded, but concedes she hasn't requested a personalized…

Supporters of Qualls, Cranley turn up the heat
Supporters of Qualls, Cranley turn up the heat

Roxanne Qualls is being criticized for selling properties along the streetcar route, while John Cranley is accused of buying political support.

Firms get $7M-plus in 1st year of parking lease
Firms get $7M-plus in 1st year of parking lease

Contractors hired by the Port Authority to operate Cincinnati's parking meters and garages would get at least $7 million in payments…

Could the streetcar project be canceled?
Could the streetcar project be canceled?

More than $22 million has already been spent on Cincinnati's streetcar project, but John Cranley wants to cancel it. Roxanne Qualls says…

Police union endorses Cranley for mayor
Police union endorses Cranley for mayor

Cincinnati's police union announced endorsements in the mayoral and City Council races.

Qualls accidentally uses Charter name on fliers
Qualls accidentally uses Charter name on fliers

Cincinnati mayoral candidate Roxanne Qualls' use of the Charter Committee's name and bulk mail permit on mass mailings are raising…