Rick Santorum campaign waits for results in Steubenville, Ohio
Hide Caption

Super Tuesday voters assess pros and cons of field

a a a a
Share this story

WASHINGTON (AP) - Voters at Super Tuesday precincts drew a composite sketch, of sorts, of the Republican candidate they'd most like to have to challenge President Barack Obama in the fall. He'd possess Mitt Romney's economic cred, Rick Santorum's heartfelt conservatism and Newt Gingrich's intellect.

Or, he would just be Ronald Reagan instead.

Not everyone who came out to churches, schools and rec centers was brimming with confidence about Republican chances once the party has its nominee. In a bruising campaign pocked with attack ads, the flaws of the hopefuls were in stark relief.

Robert G. Reed, 76, of Anderson Township in suburban Cincinnati, summed up the minuses as he sees them, practically in one breath: "Romney is too rich, Santorum is too religious, Ron Paul is too old, and I just don't like Gingrich." Reed, an independent who is retired from working on gas lines, voted for Santorum anyway.

But at a church precinct in Fayetteville, Ga., not-so-glum businessman Glenn Valencia spoke as if reading from Romney's playbook in characterizing what the former Massachusetts governor and venture capitalist has to offer the party and the country.

"You compare Obama with Romney - Obama big spender, community organizer," he said. "Romney - business organizer, wealth builder, a guy who knows how to make money and has done well, and that's what he's done for a profession, is turn around companies. And that's what we need to do, is turn around the economy."

Still, in suburbs across Ohio, the most fiercely contested state Tuesday, voters spoke of the "painful" campaign and the toll it could take on the eventual nominee.

"I haven't liked the way they've dismembered each other," said Barry Hunter, 65, a retired pharmaceutical-company manager in Dublin, outside Columbus. "They've all been pretty cutthroat." He backed Gingrich.

In suburban Cleveland, Matt Howells, 52, a contractor and Santorum voter, worried that the rivals have merely managed to harm Republican prospects in November with all that negativity. "They really have an uphill battle," he said. "I really don't see a Republican winning the White House. I see it going down as Obama again."

Similar worries were heard in some of the nine other states where people voted or caucused Tuesday.

In Edmond, Okla., Tricia Tetreault, 49, voted for Gingrich, whom she considered the best in a humdrum field. It was enough to make her pine for the Grand Old Party's good old days.

"Ronald Reagan isn't available anymore," she lamented. "What can I say?"

But Romney appealed to Heather Froelich, 40, of Westerville just outside of Columbus. She's a registered Republican and textbook editor who survived layoffs in December but saw some of her friends lose their jobs. "I know that he understands the economy," she said. "He has the right experience and values."

She likes him, too, which she can't say about others in the race.

"Santorum just bores me to tears," she said. And "I don't like Gingrich's whole approach, the way he comes across, his personal life."

At an elementary school in suburban North Royalton near Cleveland, aircraft mechanic Mike Reardon went with his gut - Santorum - even though his head might have told him Romney's got the best shot for Republicans in the fall. "I think he's a good conservative," he said of Santorum. "I don't know if he would be the best to go up against Obama but he's my personal favorite."

Cathy McDevitt, 52, a Westerville doctor who describes herself as a moderate Republican, voted for Paul because he's the only "peace candidate." But she imagines she'll back Romney in the presidential election if he becomes the candidate - despite voting for Obama in 2008.

"I feel that he has just been ineffective as a leader, in terms of runaway spending," she said of Obama. "I think that the U.S. economy doesn't have a chance as long as stuff like that continues. And I think that Mitt Romney is somebody who might be able to start turning that around."

Not all who voted in GOP primaries had the party's interests at heart. Wayne Renardson, 69, a retired jazz musician in Nashville and "political animal," voted for Santorum "because he's the easiest to beat" for Obama. "The Republicans are absolute clowns - all of `em," he said before hopping on a motorcycle and riding away.

At various precincts around the country, people had nice things to say about Gingrich's intelligence and his taste for big ideas. But there was plenty of talk, too, about baggage, which prominently includes his acknowledgments of past marital infidelity.

At an Atlanta precinct where she voted for Romney, Lena Sisselman, 96, summed up those concerns about Gingrich more pointedly than most.

"I think Gingrich is a smart man, but he's out of place," she said. "And I think he hadn't known how to zip up his pants."


Woodward reported from Washington. Associated Press writers Thomas J. Sheeran in Strongsville, Ohio; Lisa Cornwell in Anderson Township, Ohio; Ken Miller in Edmond, Okla.; Marina Hutchinson in Fayetteville, Ga.;

Peter Prengaman in Atlanta; and Joe Edwards in Nashville, Tenn., contributed to this report.

1 2

Copyright Copyright 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Print this article


Hmm... It looks like you’re not a WCPO Insider. or Subscribe now to contribute!

More Democracy 2012
Kenton Co. clerk: 'Permission is power'
Kenton Co. clerk: 'Permission is power'

The Kenton County clerk, who comes from a long line of policy-changers and milk farmers, was recently honored for making a difference in…

PODCAST: Update on Ohio same-sex marriage effort
PODCAST: Update on Ohio same-sex marriage effort

Political Cocktail's podcast version will alternate on Mondays with the video version of the show. Listen to local political news and…

Ohio AG rejects 'voter bill of rights' wording
Ohio AG rejects 'voter bill of rights' wording

Ohio Attorney Mike DeWine rejected a summary for a ballot issue to create a “voter bill of rights,” stating it wasn't…

See who's running in Kentucky's primary election
See who's running in Kentucky's primary election

More than 850 candidates have filed with the state or their county clerk’s office for the more than 300 offices on the ballot this year…

Q&A: US Senate contender Alison Lundergan Grimes
Q&A: US Senate contender Alison Lundergan Grimes

WCPO's Northern Kentucky reporter Jessica Noll asks US Senate contender and Secretary of State, Alison Lundergan Grimes, what issues…

Ohio's chief justice: Change judicial elections
Ohio's chief justice: Change judicial elections

Chief Justice Maureen O'Connor thinks changes would lessen voter apathy and may improve quality of judges.

Vote recount stays the same on Fairfield bond
Vote recount stays the same on Fairfield bond

 Parents and staff in the Fairfield School District could learn Wednesday whether or not a levy floated in November passed or not.

Cranley, council plan two swearing-in events
Cranley, council plan two swearing-in events

Cincinnati's charter requires the mayor and City Council to take their oaths of office at 11 a.m. Dec. 1 -- which is a Sunday this year.

Lakota school levy passes after official count
Lakota school levy passes after official count

Butler County elections officials say the $13.8 million school tax levy, which unofficially passed by a razor thin margin on Nov. 5, has…

Cranley will discuss streetcar cash in D.C.
Cranley will discuss streetcar cash in D.C.

A day after Cincinnati voters elected a mayor and a City Council majority opposed to the streetcar, more battles are brewing over the project.