File photo. Credit: CNN
Hide Caption

Flu shot did poor job against worst bug in seniors

a a a a
Share this story

 ATLANTA (AP) -- For those 65 and older, this season's flu shot is only 9 percent effective against the most common and dangerous flu bug, according to a startling new government report.

Flu vaccine tends to protect younger people better than older ones and never works as well as other kinds of vaccines. But experts say the preliminary results for seniors are disappointing and highlight the need for a better vaccine.

For all age groups, the vaccine's effectiveness is moderate at 56 percent, which is nearly as well as other flu seasons, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said Thursday.

For those 65 and older, it is 27 percent effective against the three strains in the vaccine, the lowest in about a decade but not far below from what's expected. But the vaccine did a particularly poor job of protecting older people against the harshest flu strain, which is causing most of the illnesses this year. CDC officials say it's not clear why.

Vaccinations are now recommended for anyone over 6 months, and health officials stress that some vaccine protection is better than none at all. While it's likely that older people who were vaccinated are still getting sick, many of them may be getting less severe symptoms.

"Year in and year out, the vaccine is the best protection we have," said CDC flu expert Dr. Joseph Bresee.

To be sure, the preliminary data for seniors is less than definitive. It is based on fewer than 300 people scattered among five states.

But it will no doubt surprise many people that the effectiveness is that low, said Michael Osterholm, a University of Minnesota infectious disease expert who has tried to draw attention to the need for a more effective flu vaccine.

Among infectious diseases, flu is considered one of the nation's leading killers. On average, about 24,000 Americans die each flu season, according to the CDC.

This flu season started in early December, a month earlier than usual, and peaked by the end of year. Older people are most vulnerable to flu and its complications, and the nation has seen some of the highest hospitalization rates for people 65 and older in a decade.

Flu viruses tend to mutate more quickly than others, and it's not unusual for multiple strains to be spreading at the same time. A new vaccine is formulated each year targeting the three strains expected to be the major threats. But that involves guesswork.

Because of these challenges, scientists tend to set a lower bar for flu vaccine. While childhood vaccines against diseases like measles are expected to be 90 or 95 percent effective, a flu vaccine that's 60 to 70 percent effective in the U.S. is considered pretty good.

By that standard, this year's vaccine is OK. The 56 percent effectiveness figure means people have a 56 percent lower chance of winding up at the doctor for treatment of flu symptoms.

For seniors, a flu vaccine is considered pretty good if it's in the 30 to 40 percent range, said Dr. Arnold Monto, a University of Michigan flu expert.

Older people have weaker immune systems that don't respond as well to flu shots. That's why a high-dose version was recently made available for those 65 and older. The new study was too small to show whether that made a difference this year.

The CDC estimates are based on about 2,700 people who got sick in December and January. The researchers traced back to see who had gotten flu shots and who hadn't. An earlier study put the vaccine's overall effectiveness slightly higher, at 62 percent.

The CDC's Bresee said there's a danger in providing preliminary results because it may result in people doubting - or skipping - flu shots. But the data was released to warn older people who got shots that they may still get sick and shouldn't ignore any serious flu-like symptoms, he said.

The new data highlights an evolution in how experts are evaluating flu vaccine effectiveness. For years, it was believed that if the viruses in the vaccine matched the ones spreading around the country, then the vaccine would be effective. This year's shot was a good match to the bugs going around this winter, including the harsher H3N2 that tends to make people sicker.

But the season proved to be a moderately severe one, with many illnesses occurring in people who'd been vaccinated.

Copyright Copyright 2013 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Print this article

Comments

Hmm... It looks like you’re not a WCPO Insider. or Subscribe now to contribute!

More Flu News
Report: Flu deaths linked to lack of vaccination
Report: Flu deaths linked to lack of vaccination

A new report from the journal Pediatrics claims healthy children can die from the flu if they do not get vaccinated.

New app aims to track flu, rein in its spread
New app aims to track flu, rein in its spread

Developed in Cincinnati by Survey Analytics, the OutSmart Flu app is being test on the University of Wisconsin campus in Madison this…

NKY sees spike in severity of flu cases
NKY sees spike in severity of flu cases

As spring blooms, you might think it's safe to stop worrying about the flu, but Northern Kentucky officials say the severity of recent flu…

Flu kills 105 kids, most not vaccinated
Flu kills 105 kids, most not vaccinated

Health officials say the flu season is winding down, and it has killed 105 children - about the average toll.

Flu shot did poor job in seniors
Flu shot did poor job in seniors

For those 65 and older, this season's flu shot is only 9 percent effective against the most common and dangerous flu bug, according to a…

Tri-State flu outbreak slows
Tri-State flu outbreak slows

This season's flu outbreak is slowing in the Tri-State, tracking new national figures released last week indicating flu activity nationwide…

CDC: Flu seems to level off
CDC: Flu seems to level off

New government figures show that flu cases seem to be leveling off nationwide. Flu activity is declining in most regions although still…

Infant flu cases up 40% in Ohio
Infant flu cases up 40% in Ohio

Infant flu cases are surpassing epidemic levels in Ohio, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Flu fuels debate over paid PTO laws
Flu fuels debate over paid PTO laws

An unusually early and vigorous flu season is drawing attention to a cause that has scored victories but also hit roadblocks in recent years:…

CDC: Flu season bad one for the elderly
CDC: Flu season bad one for the elderly

The number of older people hospitalized with the flu has risen sharply, prompting federal officials to take unusual steps to make more flu…