(Terry Helmer/9 News)
Hide Caption

Ryan Widmer seeks fourth trial at U.S. Supreme Court for the murder of his wife

a a a a
Share this story

Reported on Good Morning Tri-State by 9 On Your Side reporter Mario Ramirez.

CINCINNATI -- Jailed and facing the possibility of life in prison, Ryan Widmer is seeking a fourth trial in the murder of his wife on Monday.

Widmer is serving 15 years to life for a 2011 murder conviction in which he drowned his wife, Sarah Widmer, in their home's bathtub.

Widmer has already lost four appeals in the state's Court of Appeals but he’s hoping to have better luck with the U.S. Supreme Court.

The latest appeal filed focuses mainly on the lead investigator in the 2008 murder and a question of DNA evidence omitted during previous trials.

A Warren County judge previously denied a request to test Widmer’s wife’s DNA to see whether she had a rare genetic disease called Long QT that may have caused her to pass out in the bathtub, according to the Hamilton Journal News.

It was ruled that Sarah’s DNA would be preserved but former Judge Neal Bronson denied the request to have a private company test the material.

“Since this court has held that no convicted criminal, including petitioner, has a right to post-conviction access to the prosecution’s evidence in order to apply new DNA testing, Ohio’s statutory scheme for post-conviction DNA testing cannot and does not violate substantive due process,” Assistant Prosecutor John Arnold, who handled all three Widmer trials, wrote.

Arnold also said the juries heard large amounts of testimony from medical experts about several different ailments Sarah might have suffered from that could have caused her to pass out in the bathtub, according to the Hamilton Journal News. Arnold said a staged 911 call, dry drowning scene and bruising on Sarah’s neck can’t be overridden by DNA testing.

“Assuming that such DNA testing is available and if it revealed that Sarah had a genetic predisposition for Long QT, such a result would be irrelevant to this case, since it is not outcome determinative,” Arnold wrote. “Long QT does not change or explain the evidence which led the jury to conclude that petitioner murdered Sarah.”

The first trial ended in a conviction that was overturned after reports of juror misconduct. A second trial ended in a hung jury and the third found him guilty of murder and he was sent to prison.

The high court justices will consider an appeal Monday morning. Court officials said the decision whether the court will take the case could be announced the same day.

For the full Hamilton Journal News article, click here: http://www.todayspulse.com/news/news/widmer-prosecutors-ask-supreme-court-to-deny-appea/nZ239/

Copyright 2013 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Print this article

Comments

Hmm... It looks like you’re not a WCPO Insider. or Subscribe now to contribute!

More Local News
7 signs Lent is almost over
7 signs Lent is almost over

Sick of a certain Friday evening meal? Seeing tropical greenery around time? All good things must come to an end--even Lent. Here are the signs.

7 signs it's spring in the Tri-State
7 signs it's spring in the Tri-State

It's officially spring, so you know what that means.

Fairfield teacher's racial comment ends his job
Fairfield teacher's racial comment ends his job

The Fairfield City School District reached the decision Thursday evening to terminate a teacher's contract, after his racial comment…

Family 'prays steps' to show love of their son
Family 'prays steps' to show love of their son

Maria and Christi O’Brien, a faith-filled couple from Morrow, plan to carry their health-challenged young son up the 98 steps at…

Cincinnati Works helps the poor help themselves
Cincinnati Works helps the poor help themselves

At a time when Cincinnati's economic fortunes are on the rise, too many of its residents are being left behind. Cincinnati Works is there…

High-speed police chase ends in man's bedroom
High-speed police chase ends in man's bedroom

A high-speed police chase began on I-275, after a man stole a car from Dayton, Ky., and drove to Union Township, crashing into the bedroom of…

Nationally-praised pizza coming to Cincinnati
Nationally-praised pizza coming to Cincinnati

The Queen City is about to be delivered an award-winning slice of pizza.

Chad Johnson hopes to make comeback in Canada
Chad Johnson hopes to make comeback in Canada

Former Bengals star Chad Johnson will make his return to the gridiron with the Montreal Alouettes of the Canadian Football League.

Child struck by vehicle in Evanston
Child struck by vehicle in Evanston

A child was hospitalized Thursday evening after being struck by a vehicle in Evanston.

NKU reforms aim to prevent another money scandal
NKU reforms aim to prevent another money scandal

Northern Kentucky University's former athletic director got away with stealing $311,000 during a six-year spree.