Man and horse killed after Amish buggy and pickup truck collide

VERSAILLES, Ind. -- One man is dead after a horse and buggy collided with a pickup truck late Thursday evening.

Daniel X. Stoltzfus Jr., 18, of Versailles died in the accident. 

Indiana State Police say Stoltzfus was operating what they describe to be an Amish buggy, traveling northbound on U.S. 421 around 10 p.m., when for unknown reasons, the buggy crossed into the southbound lane where it was struck head on by a truck, driven by Wilma Asher, 53, of Versailles. 

The impact killed the horse instantly and ejected Stoltzfus from the buggy into the northbound lanes where police believe he was struck by one or two other vehicles, resulting in the fatal injures. 

Indiana State Police are looking into the safety of the buggy, saying it was equipped with modern features such as LED lights. A trooper saw the buggy about two miles before the scene of the incident, saying he saw lights on and that things seemed fine.

"There has been an influx of Amish in Ripley County," said Master Trooper Ben Bastin, with the Indiana State Police. "This means there's a bigger chance for accidents."

About 20 Amish families moved into the Indiana area from western Kentucky five years ago. Stoltzfus was well-known in his community as a "horse trainer."

The family commented, saying they believe Stoltzfus may have fallen asleep. They do not believe the accident was caused by the horse being "spooked."

Despite that fact, some residents say the believe accidents like these are going to happen more often on Route 421.

"What happened (Thursday) night is going to happen again and again and again because there's a lot of semi traffic through here. You know, 60 mile per hour plus," said Danny Matzet.

Leaders in the Amish community told 9 On Your Side they have no plans to avoid the highway.

No other drivers were injured and the crash remains under investigation.

Family members said funeral services for Stoltzfus are scheduled to take place Saturday.

---

9 On Your Side reporter Scott Wegener contributed to this report.

Print this article Back to Top

Comments

or Subscribe now so you can share your opinion! It’s only a penny for a month trial.

Latest Forecast
More Local News
Bengals put Geno Adkins, Leon Hall on PUP list
Bengals put Geno Adkins, Leon Hall on PUP list

The Bengals placed nine players on the physically unable to perform list as they prepare to open training camp Thursday.

From working on jets to crafting fine chocolates
From working on jets to crafting fine chocolates

From his previous career working on jet engines as a mechanical engineer to a world filled with cocoa beans, Paul Picton turned a passion…

Man charged with murder in fatal home invasion
Man charged with murder in fatal home invasion

A man accused in a deadly Hamilton home invasion has been charged with murder.

Injured may be part of medical trial without OK
Injured may be part of medical trial without OK

Researchers at University of Cincinnati Medical Center are preparing to take part in a national trial that could someday involve…

Cincy native, author Thomas Berger dies at 89
Cincy native, author Thomas Berger dies at 89

The witty and eclectic novelist who reimagined the American West in the historical yarn "Little Big Man" has died in New York.…

Stink forces city to address compost site issue
Stink forces city to address compost site issue

People in Winton Hills are putting up a stink about an awful smell coming from a compost site.

Mom charged in baby's drowning gets 5 years
Mom charged in baby's drowning gets 5 years

A mother charged in the drowning of her 5-month-old son was sentenced Tuesday to five years behind bars.

Lone wolf terror attack security concern for ASG
Lone wolf terror attack security concern for ASG

A lone-gunman scenario is the top security concern for public safety officials here the MLB All-Star Game comes to Cincinnati next year.

Defense lets Reds down again in 5-2 loss
Defense lets Reds down again in 5-2 loss

Milwaukee scored three runs on two misjudged balls in the outfield by Chris Heisey.

Police seek Colerain Twp. shooting suspect
Police seek Colerain Twp. shooting suspect

One person was hospitalized Monday night after being shot in Colerain Township.