Photo Video
Photo illustration Disney photo courtesy Getty Images
Hide Caption

Butler County woman accused of duping families in Disney World vacation package scam

a a a a
Share this story

MIDDLETOWN, Ohio -- A Butler County woman is accused of booking bogus Disney World vacations in an elaborate scam.

Lisa Andres, 40, was arrested Monday on a separate charge of stealing $11,000.

Several people have claimed they paid Andres thousands of dollars for what they thought were deals to Disney World.

Tri-State resident Jennifer Zale said she is one of those victims and arrived at Disney World to find nothing booked after dealing with Andres.

"We didn't get to stay where we were supposed to stay,” said Zale. “We didn't have any passes. We had no meal plan or anything. We had to buy our entire vacation all over again."

Zale’s mother, Pam Zale, said her family was cheated out of thousands.

"We gave her $5,000,” Pam said. “We had to spend another $5,000 to redo what we paid for."

Each woman said they met Andres at a Fairfield gym.

During conversations there, they claim Andres promised to get them vacation deals or have them invest in a fake vacation and timeshare business.

“You not only feel upset, but you feel really stupid,” said Butler County resident Jennifer Dendler, who claims she was a victim of Andres. “I consider myself a somewhat intelligent person and when you find things out like this, you wonder, ‘What did I not see? What did I not do?’"

Natalie Josselyn also said she invested with Andres, only to learn later she was duped.

Josselyn claims she lost $20,000 to a scam perpetrated by Andres.

“All along I would be trying to collect the money and said, ‘Where's the profit?’ Can I come over and visit?’” Josselyn said. “I'm humiliated. I feel embarrassed. I get angry and sad because I think of the people that she's hurt."

Butler County Prosecutor Mike Gmoser’s office would not comment Tuesday on the investigation into Andres’ case.

According to the alleged victims, the Butler County Prosecutor's Office may have as many as 35 cases of fraud they are investigating relating to Andres.

The women are asking that anyone who may have dealt with Andres tell authorities.

A bond was set at $5,000 for Andres Tuesday in her theft case. She will be back in court on Jan. 14 at 1 p.m.

WCPO was unable to contact Andres Tuesday for comment.

Copyright 2014 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Print this article

More Butler County News
5 arrested in Middletown heroin, cocaine bust
5 arrested in Middletown heroin, cocaine bust

Five months of investigating led police to make a drug bust and arrest five people in Middletown on Wednesday.

Katelyn Markham's father finds little comfort
Katelyn Markham's father finds little comfort

Days after searchers found more remains  that could belong to Katelyn Markham, her father said he’s found little relief concerning…

Sheriff reviewing Chelsea Johnson homicide case
Sheriff reviewing Chelsea Johnson homicide case

Saying the dead girl's mother begged him to get involved, the Butler County sheriff says his investigators are reviewing the 2012 killing…

Additional remains found in Katelyn Markham case
Additional remains found in Katelyn Markham case

Additional skeletal remains were found this week at the site where authorities discovered the bones of 21-year-old Katelyn Markham one year earlier.

Man in deadly hit-and-run pleads not guilty
Man in deadly hit-and-run pleads not guilty

A man accused of running over and killing a woman in Butler County over the weekend pleaded not guilty Tuesday.

PD: Man jailed in hit-and-run that killed woman
PD: Man jailed in hit-and-run that killed woman

A woman is dead after deputies said she was hit by a man’s vehicle early Saturday in Butler County.

Crews continue search for clues in Markham case
Crews continue search for clues in Markham case

Searchers once again combed through a tree-covered creek bed in eastern Indiana on Saturday trying to find the clues they need to answer the…

Hamilton community rallies to call for peace
Hamilton community rallies to call for peace

Church leaders came together in one Butler County community Saturday night to pray for peace after a recent string of violence in the area.

Police: Woman found dead along Liberty Twp. road
Police: Woman found dead along Liberty Twp. road

A woman was found dead in the 5500 block of Cincinnati-Dayton Road just after midnight Saturday.

TriHealth to expand Bethesda Butler Hospital
TriHealth to expand Bethesda Butler Hospital

A multi-million dollar expansion this spring at a Butler County hospital will bring with it increased health care options for patients and…