Target vs Penney: Have the tables turned?

Don't Waste Your Money

Think back a year ago:  Target was the hottest, trendiest discount department store around.

JC Penney was a disaster, with some analysts predicting it might not last another year.

But now, the picture is very different.

2013:  Penny's Really Bad Year

It was last May when a Don't Waste Your Money undercover investigation found JC Penney placing higher priced stickers over their original prices.

The story became national news after our report, and was just part of JC Penny's really bad year. The slick store redesigns didn't work, sales plunged, and the CEO got canned.

Target, at the same time was every woman's favorite discount store, with designer goods at Walmart prices.

But this year the tables have turned.

Forbes Magazine says Penney may be the next "Great American Comeback Story," with sales up as it returns to its humble roots.

Doesn't That Stink?

And from the "doesn't that stink" file, Target's fall from grace.

The massive data breach compromising millions of credit cards left a bad taste in shoppers mouths.

Target income plunged 40% in the last quarter, as nervous shoppers stayed away. If your card was involved you might have said "doesn't that stink."

Target's CEO says the store will work tirelessly to regain the confidence of customers.

Based on recent sales, it has work to do.

The good news in all this turmoil for shoppers is that you can expect more sales this spring and summer, as both chains work hard to regain the consumers they've lost the last year or two.

And that way you don't waste your money.

__________________________________

Don't Waste Your Money is a registered trademark of the EW Scripps Co.

"Like" John Matarese on Facebook

Follow John on Twitter (@JohnMatarese)

 

Print this article Back to Top

Comments

or Subscribe now so you can share your opinion! It’s only a penny for a month trial.

Latest Forecast
More DWYM
Best deals, discounts for a Cincy 'Staycation'
Best deals, discounts for a Cincy 'Staycation'

John Matarese shows how to get discount tickets for local vacation attractions.

Why you may be killing your washer & dryer
Why you may be killing your washer & dryer

John Matarese shows the mistakes many of us make

Why don't ice cream sandwiches melt anymore?
Why don't ice cream sandwiches melt anymore?

John Matarese looks into one mom's question about her kids' ice cream.

Netflix movies stink? New way to find the gems
Netflix movies stink? New way to find the gems

John Matarese shows a better way to find good movies on Netflix

Surprise! Delta may carry off your carry-on bag
Surprise! Delta may carry off your carry-on bag

John Matarese reports on an airport surprise for many travelers

Cincinnati Bell Wireless customers want answers
Cincinnati Bell Wireless customers want answers

John Matarese looks into questions surrounding the sale to Verizon.

Sign up: NEW Don't Waste Your Money newsletter
Sign up: NEW Don't Waste Your Money newsletter

John Matarese is back with a new improved newsletter!

Six lawsuits that could mean extra money for you
Six lawsuits that could mean extra money for you

John Matarese shows how you may be able to get money back from some products

9 brands that may disappear in 2015
9 brands that may disappear in 2015

Each year, once popular brands disappear into the abyss due to corporate mergers and acquisitions, as well as weak products and poor management.

App of the Week
App of the Week

Check out John Matarese's latest money saving smartphone apps.