Do we hype weather or is it the huge news universe?

Hard to imagine hype when Americans died this time

Hurricane_Irene_hub_generic_640x480_20110728142337_320_240_20110828220946_JPG

Weather Coverage-Is it hype?
Copyright 2011 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

NY_HurricaneIrene_Coverage_8-25-11_20110828221138_JPG

New York television stations covering Hurricane Irene
Copyright 2011 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

1314554216533_20110828221045_JPG

Jim Cantore of The Weather Channel covering Hurricane Irene
Copyright 2011 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

hurricane-irene-nasa-photo-537x357_20110828220835_JPG

NASA Image-Hurricane Irene
Copyright 2011 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Advertisement

Posted: 08/28/2011

Here we go...time to scream "Hype!"

Since I really didn't have a dog in the hunt this time around, I'm intrigued by the typical television bashing that goes on after a severe weather event. Columnists act like farm animals jumping on the "Hype-Bandwagon" because televison news outlets are an easy target.

Let's take a moment to re-cap Hurricane Irene.

LA TIMES: At least 19 people were killed in various storm-related accidents from Florida to Connecticut, and the death toll was expected to rise. And up to four million power customers, fairly evenly scattered along the hurricane’s path, still had no electricity on Sunday afternoon.
Across the length of the hurricane’s path, hundreds if not thousands of roads remained closed.

It seems hard to imagine someone using the phrase "dodged the bullet" with these preliminary statistics. Sure, the storm was not as strong as the computer and human forecasters predicted. And this, of course, starts the haters bleating, "hype, hype, hype!"

What exactly do some folks think is going on behind closed doors? Do people really think forecasters, news managers, and television executives sit around and scheme ways to hype the story? "Frank, Cheryl, contact our ad agency and ask them for ways to scare the beegeeus out of the audience."

Naturally, I watched an extensive amount of the coverage from ABC, CNN, and The Weather Channel. Not once did anyone, that I saw, fail to mention the potential for a calamity. In addition, the coverage was certainly warranted given the apparent strength, intensity and position of Hurricane Irene. Even President Obama said this could be a "historic" storm. Did the White House staff decide to "hype" the story too?

What's the solution here in an open market? Should CNN get with ABC and decide when each should go on and follow with the other's coverage later. Should we create a giant news cabal, or hand over the journalistic freedom to the government. Every news outlet carries their coverage as along as deemed necessary.

So, if you want to complain about the quantity of coverage, you have a point. Today. even ESPN used a radar picture with an update on Irene. Yet, it wasn't "hype". Irene's forecast changed the timing on the Little League World Series. When will these sheep understand this isn't hype...it's coverage! News organizations have to act independently which can lead to enormous amounts across the television spectrum...but it's coverage!

Now, I won't disagree that news managers sometimes make decisions based on ratings. I wish television news could return to the days of Cronkite, Murrow or even Brinkley. But, that ship has sailed. News is now a business and not a complete public service anymore. But, rarely, if ever, have I seen or known about circumstances that change coverage to hype a story.

The importance of the story dictates the amount of coverage necessary. There were roughly 65 million reasons to extensively cover Hurricane Irene. More importantly, you always forecast on the side of least regret. It will always save more lives and property.

Perhaps, these sheep will remember to put some context into their perspective next time.

Copyright 2011 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

  • Comments
  • Marketplace
Cincinnati, OH 
73° Clear
Advertisement
  • More Weather News
Get Ready: Preparing you for severe weather
Get Ready: Preparing for severe weather

9 News has loads of severe weather preparedness information …

Tropical storm warnings for Southeast coast
Tropical storm warnings for Southeast

Forecasters have issued tropical storm warnings for the …

2012 Hurricane Season Prediction
Prediction is out for hurricane season

Hurricane season begins in just 8 days...what can you expect at…

Photos show Joplin's triumphant recovery
Photos show Joplin's triumphant…

A year since a tornado destroyed a third of Joplin, three …

Hot weather expected this holiday weekend
A/Cs working overtime this weekend

The brief break from the heat is over and 90s are in the …

Twister touches down during Kansas wedding
Twister touches down during KS wedding

An outdoor ceremony in rural central Kansas made for some …

Joplin commemorates anniversary of deadly tornado
Joplin commemorates tornado anniversary

A year after a massive tornado tore through Joplin, reminders …

Flash Flood Warning expires
Flash Flood Warning expires

The Flash Flood Warning issued for counties in Ohio and …

Tropical Storm Alberto hovers off Carolina coast
Alberto hovers off Carolina coast

Tropical Storm Alberto weakened slightly off the South Carolina…

Tropical Storm Alberto forms off SC coast
Alberto first Atlantic storm of season

Alberto, the first tropical storm of the Atlantic Hurricane …

 
  • Stay Connected