More evidence to be released in Trayvon Martin case, judge rules

George Zimmerman_20120604161739_JPG

SANFORD, FL- JUNE 3: George Zimmerman (R) is escorted out of a van in to the Seminole County Jail as he surrenders to authorities after he had his bond revoked because of allegedly misleading the court about his finances June 3, 2012 in …

Trayvon Martin_20120326143436_JPG

Trayvon Martin_20120328163158_JPG

Trayvon Martin
Courtesy of CNN
Copyright 2012 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Trayvon Martin_20120328163158_JPG

Trayvon Martin
Courtesy of CNN
Copyright 2012 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

trayvon_parents_20120411191330_JPG

Parents of Trayvon Martin, mother Sybrina Fulton (R) and Tracy Martin watch a news conference with special prosecutor Angela Corey in Sanford, Fla. (Photo by Evan Vucci-Pool/Getty Images)
Copyright Getty Images

Trayvon Martin murder crime scene_20120518104146_JPG

Wideshot of Trayvon Martin murder crime scene. (Samford Police Dept.)

Trayvon Martin murder crime scene_20120518104147_JPG

Wideshot of Trayvon Martin murder crime scene. (Samford Police Dept.)

A1_20120518060455_JPG

While questions still remain, what happened the night George Zimmerman killed Trayvon Martin has become clearer with the release of medical examiner's reports, photos and video.
Photographer: Sanford PD

Advertisement

Posted: 06/13/2012

(CNN) -- A judge has ordered the release of additional evidence in the Trayvon Martin case, including an autopsy report, photographs of the crime scene and details of what George Zimmerman said to police the night he shot the Florida teen.

Attorneys for Zimmerman had argued that his conversations with Sanford, Florida, police the night of the February 26 shooting should not be made public under a state law dealing with "the substance of a confession of a person arrested," but Circuit Judge Kenneth R. Lester Jr. ruled Tuesday that the law did not apply.

"The only element conceded by the defendant is that he shot and killed the victim, but he does not concede any other elements of second-degree murder. ... Since the defendant admitted at his bond hearing that he shot the victim, disclosure of those statements will not impact the defendant's right to a fair trial," Lester said in a written order. His ruling was in response to media requests for the release of more information in the case.

E-mails to the Sanford Police Department, cell phone records listing dates and times that Zimmerman contacted police and copies of witness statements should be released, Lester said.

But Lester ruled that the court would not release the names and addresses of witnesses before the trial.

"The innocent witnesses who have performed their civil and moral duty by reporting what they observed to law enforcement should not have their lives turned upside-down for having done so," he said.

Cell phone records not dealing with calls from Zimmerman to police will also remain sealed, he said, as will photographs of Martin's body after the shooting.

Prosecution and defense lawyers had argued that a host of material should remain sealed.

The intense public attention on the case is a chief reason certain information should remain out of the public eye, prosecutor Bernie de la Rionda said in a motion filed last month.

Releasing too much "will result in this matter being tried in the press rather than in court, and an inability to seat a fair and impartial jury in Seminole County," he argued. De la Rionda also voiced worries about witnesses being "reluctant to testify" for fear that their privacy would be violated and other witnesses being "harassed by media representatives."

De la Rionda also requested that the judge seal statements Zimmerman made to law enforcement officers, some of which may be used against him at trial because they were "inconsistent with the physical evidence and statements of witnesses."

Zimmerman's attorney, Mark O'Mara, filed his own motion agreeing with the prosecution's desire not to release material. He said the defense wants 1,000 e-mails received by Sanford police to be sealed, plus statements by Zimmerman.

Scott Ponce of the Miami-based law firm Holland & Knight argued for more disclosure on behalf of various newspapers, TV stations and their parent companies.

"The broad secrecy the state seeks ... is not supported by statute, constitution or case law, and it certainly cannot be justified in this prosecution," he said.

Ponce had argued that civilian witnesses' names and addresses couldn't be sealed under Florida's public records law, because they would not be "defamatory" or "jeopardize the safety" of a witness.

In his six-page order, Lester noted the media scrutiny of the case.

"News stories have been routinely disseminated presenting opinion and rumors as fact. Any person who has logged onto a news website in the last three months has at the least seen a headline relating to the case," he wrote. "As noted, common sense tells this court that the full disclosure of information, as sought by the media interveners, will irreparably harm the...ability to receive a fair trial."

Zimmerman, 28, has pleaded not guilty. He has been in custody at the Seminole County's John E. Polk Correctional Facility since June 3, two days after Lester revoked his bond. A bail hearing is scheduled for June 29.

Zimmerman's wife was charged with perjury this week for allegedly lying at his bond hearing about the couple's finances.

CNN's Vivian Kuo contributed to this report.
 

Copyright 2012 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

  • Comments
  • More Trayvon Martin Stories
Photo appears to show Zimmerman bleeding after Trayvon Martin killing
Photo appears to show Zimmerman…

A photo posted online Monday shows George Zimmerman with blood …

Fatal Florida shooting over music compared to Trayvon Martin case
Fatal FL shooting like Martin case?

The fatal shooting of a Florida teenager who was listening to …

Tentative June trial set in Trayvon Martin case
Tentative June trial set in Martin case

A judge set a tentative trial date next year for a neighborhood…

Tests only identify Zimmerman's DNA on handgun
Test ID's only Zimmerman's DNA on gun

Forensic tests made public Wednesday show that George …

New judge named in Trayvon Martin case
New judge named in Trayvon Martin case

A new judge was tapped Thursday to preside over the case of …

Judge in Trayvon Martin case to step down
Judge in Trayvon case to step down

A Florida appeals court has granted defendant George …

Zimmerman's defense team files appeal to remove judge from case
Zimmerman's defense team files appeal

Lawyers for George Zimmerman, the Florida man charged with …

Zimmerman's wife pleads not guilty on perjury charge
Zimmerman's wife pleads not guilty

The wife of George Zimmerman will not be at her scheduled …

Slain Florida teen's parents vow to turn pain into power
Slain teen's parents press for justice

The parents of Trayvon Martin vowed in Cincinnati Wednesday to …

Trayvon Martin's parents attend town hall event in downtown Cincinnati
Martin's parents attend local event

The parents of an unarmed black Florida teenager who was shot …

Advertisement

National News


  1. Policy, discretion guide sources probe

    Policy, discretion guide sources probe

    It was a rare moment in relations between the media and the government: In 2008, FBI Director Robert Mueller called the top editors at The New York Times and The Washington Post to apologize because the bureau had improperly obtained reporters' telephone records four years earlier.

    • Ex-IRS head to be grilled by Congress

      • Are some kids too smart for high school?

        • How to help victims of Okla. tornado

          • Photog: All I could see was destruction

            • Twister season starts late in Midwest

            • OK twister tracked path of 1999 tornado

               
              • Stay Connected