I-Team: You're paying to keep addicts medicated

Suboxone


Photographer: Brendan Keefe
Copyright 2012 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Heroin needle

Heroin needle.
Photographer: Brendan Keefe
Copyright 2012 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Suboxone film

Suboxone film.
Photographer: Brendan Keefe
Copyright 2012 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Suboxone dose.

Suboxone dose.
Photographer: Brendan Keefe
Copyright 2012 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Advertisement

Posted: 05/10/2012

CINCINNATI - What if there was a magic pill that could eliminate all the cravings of heroin and oxycodone addicts without making them high?

There is such a drug. It's called Suboxone, and it has become the standard of care in medically-assisted recovery.

Suboxone does everything you would want such a medication to do:

  • Eliminates withdrawal symptoms
  • Doesn't make addicts high
  • Prevents over-dose
  • Blocks drugs of abuse

"If you slip, and go out and use an opiate of abuse it has no effect whatsoever. None. They don't get high, they don't get side effects, it's like they never did it," said Dr. Todd Carran of Milford's Northland Treatment Center.

Dr. Carran has no doubt Suboxone is saving lives, in part because of the "ceiling effect" that prevents overdose.

"It doesn't matter how much you take -- you can't get past the ceiling effect," Dr. Carran said. "So you could take 200 bottles of buprenorphine -- you're not going to get high. You're also not going to die."

Buprenorphine is the key ingredient of Suboxone. The other component is naloxone, added to prevent injection abuse.

Buprenorphine is a prescription painkiller manufactured by the British pharmaceutical giant Reckitt Benckiser (read a statement from the company at http://goo.gl/6m3Zz ). There is a generic version of buprenorphine made in Columbus, but Reckitt Benckiser is still the primary producer of the drug, and the only company combining it with naloxone to make Suboxone.

The drug was approved for the treatment of opiate addiction in the United States about a decade ago. It is quickly replacing methadone as the preferred medication to treat addiction. Methadone is a liquid opiate dispensed in a clinic, and it can get patients high.

Suboxone is a pill or a gel strip the patient can take at home, with no opiate-like side effects. It acts like an inoculation against heroin and oxycontin, because it blocks those drugs from having any effect.

You may not have heard of Suboxone or buprenorphine before, but you're paying for it with your tax dollars.

Ohio's Medicaid program, administered by the Ohio Department of Job and Family Services, paid $21,400,000 to pharmacies last year for Suboxone prescriptions. That tax money kept more than 9,000 addicts medicated.

But one doctor on the Ohio Medicaid drug approval board called buprenorphine, "one of the fastest-growing street drugs."

The Drug Enforcement Administration has labeled it, "a heroin substitute," and, "a primary drug of abuse."

While an addict can't overdose on buprenorphine alone, it can be deadly if taken with benzodiazepines or alcohol. The DEA reported 14,266 emergency room visits linked to buprenorphine in 2009.

Most health insurance companies also cover the drug, which costs between $13 and $20 per daily dose.

That coverage is helping an Eastgate-area addict named Elaine with her recovery.

"With Suboxone, I don't get high at all," she said. "My life is gradually getting better and better, and I'm doing all the things I couldn't do before."

Elaine's heroin addiction had devastated her life. But with a single strip of Suboxone under her tongue each morning, she has been able to return to an otherwise-normal life.

"In the morning when I take my Suboxone, I know that I'll be OK for today," she said. That has allowed her to seek traditional peer-to-peer treatment as well.

Elaine's daily dose of Suboxone is enough to prevent withdrawal symptoms -- and block heroin from working -- for up to three days. 

"If I did want to go get high, it wouldn't do anything," she said.

But some addicts say the withdrawal from the cure is worse than that from the disease.

"Suboxone is a long, drawn-out withdrawal process," a recovering addict named Chris said.

The 22-year-old is now rebuilding his life in a 12-step recovery program. Recalling his darkest days, Chris said the only cure for his Suboxone withdrawal symptoms was heroin.

"As soon as I was taken off Suboxone, I immediately went back to my drug of choice," Chris said.

Chris told us he bought Suboxone off the street long before he was ever prescribed it as a treatment medication.

Why would an addict buy a drug that won't get him high? Because it prevents the withdrawal pains during the days between unreliable hits of heroin or oxy.



"If something that is a miracle drug that is going to help people has a street value, it contradicts itself, and I lived that first-hand," Chris said.

Chris got his eventual prescription for Suboxone from a doctor, not a treatment facility.

Doctors are required to get special training and a permit to write buprenorphine prescriptions, and they're limited to 100 patients each. Prescriptions must be renewed monthly, requiring a $150 - $250 office visit which may or may not include counseling.

Next page: Suboxone here in the Tri-State.



Outpatient treatment facilities Northland in Ohio, and Transitions in Northern Kentucky do dispense Suboxone, but only in concert with psycho-social counseling methods. Clients are required to attend meetings, and they're tested to make sure their taking their Suboxone rather than selling it on the street.

"Buprenorphine does not treat the disease," Dr. Carran said, "but it keeps people from relapsing and therefore lets them stay in treatment."

But there's debate within the medically-assisted recovery community itself -- is Suboxone a temporary treatment for the three-week withdrawal period, or is it a long-term maintenance drug?

"The current literature and the current recommendations are, you're going to need to keep people on this medication much, much longer," Dr. Carran said.

Northland clients may take Suboxone for six months to a year, but Dr. Carran said there are some rare cases that may require indefinite treatment with the medication to keep the addict from relapsing.

Elaine said she wants to quit after a year or so, but she understands why some addicts may have to take Suboxone for the rest of their lives.

"If you had any other kind of disease, you're going to take that medication to keep the disease at bay," Elaine said.

Online forums
for Suboxone patients are full of threads where addicts ask each other for advice on quitting the drug that was supposed to be their cure. There's an entire "Stopping Suboxone" chat room.

Thread titles include:

  • "Trying to quit"
  • "Suboxone for seven years and my story of addiction"
  • "When am I ever going to get off this?"
  • "Deciding to stay on Suboxone permanently??"

Several addicts ask for help "self tapering" -- the process of weaning themselves off the medication by reducing the dose, often against doctors' advice.

A self-described "breast-feeding mom" wrote after three years on Suboxone, and getting stuck at four milligrams, "I never thought in a million years I'd be on it this long."

Chris, the recovering addict from Cincinnati who spent five months on Suboxone by prescription, said he tried self-tapering.

"I would take half of what was prescribed and I would sell the rest," he said.

He said the urine tests showed he was still taking the drug because he was using half of the prescribed dose, and he would sometimes manipulate those tests with urine supplied by others.

Chris sold the other half of his prescription to fellow addicts to use as a lifeline between hits of heroin, or to get high. Buprenorphine produces a euphoric high in users who have never taken another opiate before.

"They're on the streets looking, buying, stealing for Suboxone," Chris said. "I've experienced it with other addicts that their drug of choice is Suboxone."

"They call it drug replacement because that's exactly what it is -- it's replacing one drug for another," said Ivan Faske, who runs the Serenity Recovery Network. Drugs of any kid, including prescribed treatment medications, are banned from Serenity House, a residential addiction treatment facility in East Price Hill.  

"It's really, really just dealing with the symptoms, and not dealing with the problem," said Faske.

Chris said the Suboxone numbed his brain to the point where he was not addressing the pain that was the root cause of his addiction. He said he had simply traded a street-level drug dealer for a corporate one.

"It's like a monster in a cage," Chris said, "and if I put any substance in my body, that door on that cage is unlocked, and that monster is out."

Reckitt Benckiser Pharmaceuticals gave us this statement in response to our story :

"With opioid painkiller dependence at epidemic levels in the United States, it is critical that patients and physicians are aware of all the treatment options available to them. Reckitt Benckiser Pharmaceuticals works collaboratively with physicians to ensure that patients who need our medicines have access to them and supports initiatives that encourage their responsible use.

Opioid dependence is a chronic, relapsing brain disease, and often requires long term management by a qualified healthcare professional. There is no "one size fits all" approach to treating this disease.

As with all chronic diseases, the challenges of opioid painkiller dependence are unique to each individual. Patients should identify and work with qualified health care professionals to determine what options are right for them. For some patients, this could mean a combination of FDA-approved medicines, rehabilitation centers, outpatient centers, talk therapy and/or behavioral therapy."

Copyright 2012 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

  • Comments
Advertisement

I-Team


  1. I-Team: Emails describe IRS 'criteria'

    I-Team: Emails describe IRS 'criteria'

    The I-Team has obtained emails that appear to show an early "Be On The Lookout" (BOLO) criteria list used by Cincinnati Internal Revenue Service agents to target conservative groups seeking tax-exempt status.

  2. I-Team: 911 dispatch issues affect cops

    I-Team: 911 dispatch issues affect cops

    The issues that the I-Team uncovered at Cincinnati's 911 dispatch center don't just affect those calling for help: They could also delay the city's police officers.

  3. I-Team: IRS emails raise questions

    • I-Team: City reacts to 911 investigation

    • I-Team: Is Cincinnati 911 like roulette?

    • Local IRS employee talks about scandal

    • I-Team: 5 IRS workers to be interviewed

    I-Team Investigators


    1. Brendan Keefe

      Brendan Keefe

      30-time Emmy winner Brendan Keefe was named Best Reporter by the Ohio Associated Press in 2011, and Best Photographer in 2012. He serves as Anchor and Chief Investigator for WCPO.

      • Jason Law

        Jason Law

        Jason Law joined 9 On Your Side in January 2013 as a investigative reporter with the I-Team.

         
        • Stay Connected