Pet owners baffled by 'super fleas'

Don't Waste Your Money

Puppy

File photo of a puppy
Copyright 2011 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Advertisement

Posted: 02/04/2013

Some dog and cat owners across the country have been noticing something strange the past few years: Their pets' flea and tick medicine doesn't seem to be working as well.

And fleas seem to be showing up on their pets even during the winter.

Is it their pet? New "super fleas?" Warmer weather? How they're applying the medicine? Or something else?

Nothing Seems to Work

Dean Carroll loves his two terriers, Fred and Ginger, as in the famous dancers.

But the only dancing going on in his home in Arlington Heights, Ohio, is the constant dance of fleas, for the past two years.

"Fleas have been absolutely terrible," he said. "They were scratching constantly. We were using a brush, and every day we would get eight or nine fleas off each of them, and it didn't seem to work."

Carroll tried a spray in addition to capsules and tried switching medicine. No change.

So he Googled the problem, and found dozens of other pet owners complaining, some wondering if fleas are developing a resistance to flea medicine.

"I am not a scientist, I am not a doctor, but you hear about a lot of things developing resistance these days," Carroll said.

Pet Medical Mystery
    
So we went to a Veterinary Dermatologist, Dr. Natalie Tabacca of the MedVet Medical & Cancer Centers for Pets on Red Bank Road in Cincinnati.

Dr. Tabacca says several studies by manufacturers and universities have found no evidence of resistance.

"We have not been able to demonstrate any fleas have become resistant to any product," she said.

So why are Carroll's dogs still scratching?

Despite a more "normal" winter this year, Dr Tabacca says evidence points to 2012's record warmth, and longer growing seasons in recent years.

"We're getting more fleas earlier, and they are lasting longer, " she explained. "Those eggs and pupa are hardy and can live outdoors as long as there is warm enough temperature."

Bayer, maker of K9 Advantix, agrees, telling us in a statement:

     "Recent mild winters have extended flea and tick season across the country. It now seems to be a constant pressure year-round."

Merial, maker of Frontline Plus ®, told us:

    "Perceived resistance to Frontline® plus has not been documented in any studies. When used according to the label, frontline products are highly effective."

3 Things You Can Do

So what can you do? Dr Tabacca suggests you:

    --Always apply flea medicine to the pet's skin, not fur.

    --Ask your vet if you should increase dosages (but don't do that without a vet's consent)

    --Treat your lawn for insects in the spring, if pets spend time outdoors.

What this means is that pet owners like Dean Carroll are going to have to be extra vigilant all year long.

Bottom line: If you notice a flea or tick issue this spring and summer, see your vet.

A change in medication or change in the way you apply it may be all you need. That way your pet stays happy, your house stays clean, and you don't waste your money.
____________________

Don't Waste Your Money is a registered trademark of the EW Scripps Co.

"Like" John Matarese on Facebook

Follow John on Twitter (@DWYM)

 

Copyright 2013 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

  • Comments
Advertisement
  • Statements on Flea Meds

FULL STATEMENT FROM MERIAL/FRONTLINEPLUS:

Perceived resistance to FRONTLINE® Plus has not been documented in any studies. When used according to the label, FRONTLINE brand products are highly effective in killing fleas and ticks, and preventing re-infestations. FRONTLINE Plus remains the veterinarian's number one recommendation for flea and tick control. Pet owners should talk to their veterinarian about what flea and tick product is right for their pet(s).

FULL STATEMENT FROM BAYER/K9 ADVANTIX:

Bayer HealthCare Animal Health concurs with the veterinarian that provided comment to you below. Recent mild winters have extended flea and tick season across the country. The normal seasonal cycle of tick and flea pressure is no longer as visible; it now seems to be a constant pressure year-round. We anticipate that updated data will be shared at trade conferences later this year - please feel free to check back with us then for updated information

 

Study on flea medicine resistance: http://www.veterinarypracticenews.com/vet-cover-stories/fleas-persist-but-reason-isnt-resistance.aspx

 

Bayer study on medicine efficacy: http://media2.wcpo.com/pdfs/BAYER.pdf

  • More DWYM
BBB issues alert about repair company
BBB issues alert about repair company

John Matarese has a warning about some repair companies that …

Good news: Used car prices finally drop
Good news: Used car prices finally drop

John Matarese has long-awaited good news for used car shoppers

You Win Wednesday freebies
You Win Wednesday freebies

John Matarese shares the latest freebies.

Click here for

JCPenney slaps new high prices on goods
JCPenney slaps new high prices on goods

John Matarese finds dozens of new, higher price stickers on …

EZ home inventory in case of storm
EZ home inventory in case of storm

John Matarese shows the latest ways to record your valuables, …

Do As-Seen-on-TV grout cleaners work?
Do As-Seen-on-TV grout cleaners work?

John Matarese has the newest test of bathroom and kitchen grout…

Remke-bigg's getting out of pharmacy business, transferring prescriptions to Walgreens
Remke-bigg's getting out of pharmacy…

John Matarese has big news for anyone who uses Remke-bigg's as …

$20 a month smartphone: Can it be real?
$20 a month smartphone: Can it be real?

John Matarese checks out the newest $20 a month unlimited …

PC users receive strange Microsoft call
PC users receive strange Microsoft call

John Matarese looks into a claim there is a problem with …

Duke Energy offering 2 free Reds tickets
Duke Energy offering 2 free Reds…

John Matarese looks into Duke's new offer to see if it's too …

Meet John Matarese


  1. John Matarese

    John Matarese

    A veteran reporter and two-time Emmy Award winner, John is our Don't Waste Your Money consumer reporter.

    • Send John an email, so you Don't Waste Your Money!

    You Win Wednesday


    • Stay Connected